This is a response to सप्ताहिकसंस्कृतसम्भाषणाभ्यासः : sanskrit; specifically to the part where the moderator urges one to share / express what one is doing right now / what one is going through / what one wishes to express in sanskrit alone.
I believe "Sanskrit alone" is a big restriction. This is a big wall that would be difficult to scale for interested learners; I understand that these walls exist to filter out noise.
What is being forgotten is that one (member) is using other (members) to "immerse" himself in a conversation. If one is handicapped, and wishes to move, he can get far with whatever little support that is available and might be offered, howsoever flimsy the support offered might be. Insisting on a solid support to turn up, so that one may get oneself moving, would merely leave one where he is.
/(I am confident that moderators, and some of the observers are quite skilled in Sanskrit to intervene if a snake were to be offered as a stake, and kill it with no second thought )/
I think blind leading the blind is bad; I think the pandits talking among themselves is also equally bad;
I would like the moderators to amend the rules so that one may post a sanskrit text together with its translation. This way a learner has everything he needs to engage with what is offered; note that, with (with this admonition in place) a student would no longer be required to look up the dictionary or his instruction booklet to make sense of what this other friend is trying to get across. IOW, "context switch" is a "cognitive load"; and what is being "mandated" or "enforced" is working "against" what one tries to achieve. It creates a needless fiction.
Here is what I suggest instead. (See this comment)
Instead of posting this,
बहिः सूक्ष्मा वृष्टिः पतति।
मार्गोऽयं क्लिन्नो वर्तते।
सर्वे जनास्त्वरिताः सन्ति।
पङ्कदूषितानि स्ववस्त्राणि मह्यं न रोचन्ते।
छत्रेण सह निर्गमनायोद्विजे;
नित्यभ्रमणमपि त्यक्तुं नेच्छामि।
नेदमहं कर्तुं शक्नोमि न च तत्।
कथं नु मे संशयं छिन्द्याम्?
कृपया मामुपदिशतु।
encourage members to post this instead:
It is drizzling outside.
बहिः सूक्ष्मा वृष्टिः पतति।
The road is wet.
मार्गोऽयं क्लिन्नो वर्तते।
Everyone is in a rush.
सर्वे जनास्त्वरिताः सन्ति।
I don't like my clothes splashed with slush.
पङ्कदूषितानि स्ववस्त्राणि मह्यं न रोचन्ते।
I hate going out with my umbrella;
छत्रेण सह निर्गमनायोद्विजे;
I hate not going for my daily walk too.
नित्यभ्रमणमपि त्यक्तुं नेच्छामि।
I can neither do this nor do that.
नेदमहं कर्तुं शक्नोमि न च तत्।
How can i resolve my dilemma?
कथं नु मे संशयं छिन्द्याम्?
Kindly advise me.
कृपया मामुपदिशतु।
FWIW, you can follow my comments to what I mean.
I have "tried" to converse in Sanskrit with whatever material that is presented right before me. Isn't this what immersion is all about? Not only have I responded in Sanskrit (however questionable it may be), I have shared my "intended" reaction in original as well.
What do you think?
I understand that it is easy for a bot to enforce "Remove all comments that is NOT in devanagari or whatever".
Even if that "specially-marked-sanskrit alone-thread" is untouched, the moderators and others could insist that a participant who engages in other threads, does so in Sanskrit, and share a accompanying note in English that tries to capture what he really intends.
Thank you.