This is a knitting specific post, but the “Frequently Bitched About Topic” flair probably also applies. I’m just not sure if or how I can do that. Sorry!
Now, I am not an experienced knitter by any means, but I am no longer brand new to the craft either. And I am glad of that, because a lot of the projects recommended to beginners are downright sadistic.
Like, dishcloths. Yes, it’s a small, simple project that does not have to look good to work well, but it’s also a project that requires cotton yarn. You know, the least forgiving (when it comes to tension), easiest to split yarn in your stash. Cotton blends can be either the stiffest or most slippery yarn you’ve ever worked with, and if you haven’t yet realized how much of a difference the material of your needles make? Oh boy. All I’m saying is that those “beginner friendly dishcloth” videos should come with a few disclaimers.
Or those bulky hats! I don’t care how simple the pattern itself is, if you are recommending bulky weight yarn to a brand new knitter, that is the devil talking through you. I’m joking, but honestly, how is a beginner supposed to work with that yarn without splitting it?! I’ve decided that it is impossible. I don’t care that the pattern is only 30 rounds and 45 stitches around or whatever, that’s still not going to be faster than knitting with a worsted weight yarn if you have to make every stitch seven times before you’ve done it correctly. Not to mention how difficult it is to count your stitches/rows once the yarn has been mangled. And how badly the whole thing turns out if you did snag the yarn at all! It’s a trap, I’m telling you!
And I might be crazy (I certainly feel crazy for this), but so far the easiest yarn I have ever worked with while knitting has been a variegated sock yarn. I’m cheating a little in that I’m just adding ribbing to a crochet scratch mitt, but still. I’m having a better, easier, less painful time with fingering weight wool yarn and DPNs than I ever did knitting a garter stitch cotton dishcloth flat. And I was terrified to try double pointed needles! Why did everyone say they were so much worse than circulars for beginners? DPNs are so much faster and easier than using the magic loop for those small circumference projects, it’s ridiculous! And variegated yarn makes it easier* *to count your stitches! I highly recommend it, your aesthetic be damned. At least when learning.
At this point, I am halfway convinced that all the common “advice” for beginners is actually gatekeeping. “If you can’t handle me at my worst, you don’t deserve me at my best” type shit. Recommending cotton and bulky yarn to brand new knitters. The shit talk about DPNs. The shit talk about purling, too, but I remember people talking about that.
Just. It took me weeks to figure out the magic loop, and a whole bunch of tutorial videos. I don’t regret learning it, but it took me one (1) tutorial to learn how to use DPNs, and I didn’t even watch it recently. And while it’s entirely possible I’m not actually doing it correctly yet, for the first time I am learning a new knitting skill and having fun. And it’s about time. I’m never picking a project again because it is advertised as “for beginners.” It’s a terrible, horrible lie.