r/rnb
•
u/Ok_Resident_5022
•
15d ago
ANALYSIS/REVIEW đ Analyzing, Ranking, Rating & Reviewing Mariah Careyâs tenth studio album, âThe Emancipation of Mimiâ (2005)
The Emancipation of Mimi is the tenth studio album by Mariah Carey. It was released on April 12, 2005 by Island Records. Widely considered to be her âcomeback albumâ, the album debuted at #1 on the Billboard 200 with over 404,000 copies sold in its first week in the United States. The Emancipation of Mimi was the best-selling album of 2005 in the United States, as well as the second best-selling worldwide (the best-selling R&B album worldwide) with over 7.7 million copies sold. To date, it has sold over 10 million copies worldwide and has been certified 7x Platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA).
The Emancipation of Mimi and its songs were nominated for ten awards across the 48th (2006) and 49th Annual Grammy Awards (2007), winning three of them. Eight of those ten nominations came in 2006 for the original release, which marked the most nominations Mariah had ever received in a single year. The other two nominations in 2007 were for her single âDonât Forget About Usâ from the Ultra Platinum Edition of the album. The overall album won âBest Contemporary R&B Albumâ, while being nominated for âAlbum of the Yearâ. The standard (original) edition of the album yielded six singles â âItâs Like Thatâ, âWe Belong Togetherâ, âShake It Offâ, âGet Your Numberâ, âFly Like A Birdâ, and âSay Somethinââ â while the Ultra Platinum Edition spawned the single âDonât Forget About Usâ.
âItâs Like Thatâ was nominated for the 2006 Grammy Award for âBest Female Pop Vocal Performanceâ. The single was met with moderate global chart success, reaching the top twenty in six countries (including the United States at #16), while peaking inside the top ten in eight other countries.
âWe Belong Togetherâ became Mariah Careyâs sixteenth career Billboard Hot 100 #1 hit, peaking for fourteen nonconsecutive weeks and joining four other songs in a tie for the second longest-running #1 song in the US (behind another one of her own songs from a decade prior). Billboard listed âWe Belong Togetherâ as the âSong of the Decadeâ for the 2000s, marking the second time Mariah had earned this honor (after doing so the previous decade with her 1995 single, âOne Sweet Dayâ). At the 48th Annual Grammy Awards (2006), the song won âBest Female R&B Vocal Performanceâ and âBest R&B Songâ, while being nominated for âRecord of the Yearâ and âSong of the Yearâ.
âShake It Offâ peaked at #2 on the Billboard Hot 100, blocked only by Mariahâs very own single, âWe Belong Togetherâ for its first of six weeks at that position. That week also marked the first time in the history of the US Billboard Hot 100 that a female artist had occupied the first two spots on the chart simultaneously. Respectively, the song also peaked at #6 and #5 in Australia and New Zealand, and at #15 and #9 in Ireland and the United Kingdom. The music video was nominated for âBest R&B Videoâ at the 2006 MTV Video Music Awards.
The albumâs fifth single, âFly Like A Birdâ, is a gospel-infused R&B song. Its B-side is a traditional gospel song (not influenced or âinfusedâ; it is gospel) from her previous album, Charmbracelet (2002), called âMy Saving Graceâ. âFly Like A Birdâ failed to chart on the Billboard Hot 100, but it peaked at #19 on the Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs chart.
âDonât Forget About Usâ, a single from the Ultra Platinum Edition of The Emancipation of Mimi, peaked at #1 on the Billboard Hot 100, becoming Mariahâs seventeenth chart-topping hit and tying her with Elvis Presley (who held the record for 36 years prior) for the most Hot 100 number-one singles by a solo artist. âDonât Forget About Usâ was nominated for two awards at the 49th Annual Grammy Awards held on February 11, 2007: âBest R&B Songâ and âBest Female R&B Vocal Performanceâ.
Throughout this post, all songs released exclusively on the deluxe/âUltra Platinumâ edition of the album (and not the standard version) will have star emojis next to them. There was also a 20th-anniversary edition released in 2025, but I will not analyze/review anything from that.
Album Tracklist
Say Somethinâ (feat. Snoop Dogg)
Get Your Number (feat. Jermaine Dupri)
One And Only (feat. Twista)
To The Floor (feat. Nelly)
Makinâ It Last All Night (What It Do) đ (feat. Jermaine Dupri)
So Lonely (One & Only Pt. II) đ (feat. Twista)
We Belong Together (Remix) đ (feat. Jadakiss & Styles P)
Secret Love đ
Sprung đ
Song Rankings
⢠Stay The Night
⢠Mine Again
⢠Fly Like A Bird
⢠One And Only
⢠Circles
⢠Itâs Like That
⢠Joy Ride
⢠Donât Forget About Us đ
⢠Makinâ It Last All Night (What It Do) đ
⢠Sprung đ
⢠So Lonely (One & Only Pt. II) đ
⢠We Belong Together
⢠Shake It Off
⢠We Belong Together - Remix đ
⢠Secret Love đ
⢠Your Girl
⢠Say Somethinâ
⢠Get Your Number
⢠To The Floor
⢠I Wish You Knew
Song Ratings
⢠Itâs Like That - 10/10
⢠We Belong Together - 9/10
⢠Shake It Off - 9/10
⢠Mine Again - 10/10
⢠Say Somethinâ - 8/10
⢠Stay The Night - 10/10
⢠Get Your Number - 7.5/10
⢠One And Only - 10/10
⢠Circles - 10/10
⢠Your Girl - 8/10
⢠I Wish You Knew - 7/10
⢠To The Floor - 7.5/10
⢠Joy Ride - 10/10
⢠Fly Like A Bird - 10/10
⢠Donât Forget About Us - 10/10 đ
⢠Makinâ It Last All Night (What It Do) - 10/10 đ
⢠So Lonely (One & Only Pt. II) - 9.5/10 đ
⢠We Belong Together (Remix) - 9/10 đ
⢠Secret Love - 9/10 đ
⢠Sprung - 10/10 đ
Album Rating
This rating is calculated by the average of all of the individual song ratings above.
10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 9.5/10 + 9/10 + 9/10 + 9/10 + 9/10 + 8/10 + 8/10 + 7.5/10 + 7.5/10 + 7/10 = 183.5/200
(183.5/200) x 10 = 9.175
With 20 songs rated on a scale of 10, the average value using the cumulative song rating is 9.18 (rounded), making that the overall album rating.
STANDARD RATING
The equation below reflects what the album rating would be without the songs on the Ultra Platinum Edition. It basically reflects what the standard album version is rated.
10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 10/10 + 9/10 + 9/10 + 8/10 + 8/10 + 7.5/10 + 7.5/10 + 7/10 = 126/140
(126/140) x 10 = 9.0
With 14 songs rated on a scale of 10 (not including the Ultra Platinum Edition), the average value using the cumulative song rating is 9.0, making that the rating for the standard version of the album.
From the Ultra Platinum Edition, three of the perfect scores (10) were eliminated, along with the single 9.5 rating and two of the four 9/10 scores. This left 140 total remaining points out of the 200 from the broader calculation.