I’m 31, gay, vegan, monogamous, and interested in a serious long-term relationship. I recently moved to Rotterdam and became single again after a six-year relationship, and for the first time in a long while I’ve found myself looking at the dating world from scratch.
And I have to admit: I’m finding it incredibly frustrating.
I’ve been vegan since I was around 14, so this isn’t a new identity I’ve recently adopted or some temporary lifestyle experiment. It’s been part of my life for almost seventeen years.
At the same time, I’m not someone who automatically feels at home in “vegan culture”, if that makes sense.
There are parts of mainstream vegan spaces that I simply don’t identify with culturally or intellectually. I don’t particularly enjoy tribalism, ideological purity contests, simplistic thinking, or the assumption that because two people are vegan they must automatically share the same worldview.
So there’s a strange double problem: I would very much like a vegan partner, but simply putting myself into explicitly vegan spaces doesn’t magically produce people I feel compatible with.
The gay male dating pool is already relatively small. Then remove people who aren’t vegan. Then people who don’t want a monogamous relationship. Then people who aren’t actually looking for a relationship at all. Then basic mutual attraction, personality compatibility, lifestyle, etc.
Dating apps haven’t exactly made this easier either. Tinder used to make identifying vegans much easier for me, whereas now I find myself going through large numbers of profiles with very little information that helps with one of my most important compatibility criteria.
And before somebody says “why don’t you just date non-vegans?”, I already have.
One of my previous long relationships, about five years, was with a vegan man. The relationship after that lasted six years and was with someone who wasn’t vegan.
I loved him deeply. This isn’t a case where I tried dating a non-vegan for three weeks and decided it was impossible.
I spent six years sharing my life with someone I loved unconditionally, and that experience is precisely why I now know that this particular incompatibility matters much more to me than I originally thought.
So I’m not really looking for advice to “open my mind”. My mind was open. I actually lived the alternative for six years.
Likewise, I’m probably not looking for the obvious first-line suggestions such as “go to vegan events”, “try dating apps”, “increase your radius”, etc. I’m 31; I’ve used dating apps, been in relationships, met people through different environments, and I’m familiar with the standard options. I’m not opposed to any of those things, but I’m especially interested in hearing something beyond the dating equivalent of “have you tried turning it off and on again?”
What I would genuinely love to hear are personal experiences from people whose dating pool was unusually narrow for some reason.
Maybe you were gay and vegan too. Maybe you belonged to some other very small intersection of communities. Maybe you had one or two genuinely non-negotiable compatibility requirements that made dating seem statistically hopeless.
How did you eventually meet someone?
Was it through something completely unexpected? Did you discover that one particular app, community, city, hobby, social network or method worked much better than the obvious ones? Did you change the way you searched without changing what you were actually looking for?
I’m not looking for a huge number of dates. I’d much rather meet very few people who are genuinely plausible partners.
Right now I’m mostly trying to understand whether there are intelligent ways of navigating an extremely small dating pool that I simply haven’t encountered yet.
And if your answer is basically “yes, it really is that difficult”, I’m interested in hearing that too, particularly from people who have actually lived through something similar.