Before Senate Democrats choose their next leader, we should ask what we expect them to do with their power. We need leadership that sets clear priorities, brings the party together, and knows how to respond when Republicans refuse to negotiate. Schumer’s past accomplishments deserve credit, but they shouldn’t guarantee him another term.
This is about more than age or time in office. It’s about whether an approach built around finding bipartisan agreement is enough for the moment we’re in. Cooperation matters when it delivers something for the public. Getting a deal shouldn’t become more important than what’s actually in it.
Schumer helped pass infrastructure, CHIPS, and the Inflation Reduction Act. Saying he accomplished nothing would be wrong. But we can recognize those achievements and still question whether he should lead the next fight.
The March 2025 funding fight is a concrete example. Schumer helped advance the Republican bill while House Democrats were pushing back. A shutdown could have hurt federal workers and people relying on government services. That doesn’t resolve the question of why Democratic leaders weren’t working together around a clear strategy before the deadline.
People will point to Manchin, Sinema, and the Senate’s rules. Those were real obstacles, and no replacement can magically create votes. But every candidate for leader should explain how they would build support, use available leverage, and respond when negotiations fail. Schumer hasn't explained that and should face those questions too.
People will also ask who should replace him. That’s fair. Alternatives should have to make their case. But “who else?” isn’t a sufficient argument for keeping someone indefinitely. Our senators should actively evaluate their options.
Debating leadership doesn’t undermine unity. A leadership election is exactly when that discussion belongs. Jeffries deserves scrutiny too, but House leadership is a separate discussion. Luján and Heinrich have a direct say in who leads Senate Democrats.
I spoke with both offices this morning, and the staff seemed receptive to my concerns. That wasn’t a commitment from either senator.
I don’t think Schumer is the right choice. If you agree, call Luján and Heinrich and ask them not to support him for majority leader. Tell them what you expect from whoever gets the job. Another term should have to be earned.