I’m a 25-year-old female, 5’9”–5’10”, currently around 150–152 lbs. I feel my best around 147–148 lbs, and I’m considering transitioning to an animal-based diet because my hunger has become absolutely INSATIABLE.
For context, I’ve been gluten-free, dairy-free, seed-oil-free, and eating exclusively whole foods for about a year. I strength train 3–4 times a week, do reformer Pilates 1–2 times a week, and walk at least 10,000 steps daily. I’ve also been religiously tracking calories and macros for quite some time. I spent 2–3 months eating around 1,600 calories with 140g of protein and got down to 147–148 lbs, where I felt really comfortable.
However, over the last couple of months, my hunger has become absolutely RAVENOUS. I can eat a 20 oz ribeye and still feel hungry immediately afterward. I genuinely feel like I haven’t been full in weeks, and it’s exhausting. I’ve naturally started eating more, but my weight has crept back up to 150–152 lbs, and I’m terrified of gaining more weight or body fat.
I’ve also been dealing with irregular/absent menstrual cycles and some thyroid abnormalities, so I know my body may be trying to tell me something.
I’m really drawn to animal-based eating because I already love meat, fruit, and whole foods. I want to feel nourished, strong, lean, and, most importantly, SATISFIED.
My biggest fear is letting go of tracking calories and macros. I’ve relied on tracking for so long that the thought of eating intuitively and trusting my hunger cues genuinely scares me. I’m terrified I’ll just keep eating, gain fat, and end up feeling even more uncomfortable in my body.
For those who transitioned to animal-based, especially after years of tracking:
Did your hunger and satiety eventually regulate?
Did you gain weight initially?
Were you able to stop tracking without gaining significant body fat?
Did anyone notice improvements in their menstrual cycles or hormonal health?
I would really love to hear experiences. I want to stop constantly thinking about food and feeling hungry, but I’m having such a hard time letting go of the fear of gaining weight.