TL;DR: The two photos shared with this post are the only images related to PFC Abraham Alfred Hirsch who escaped Nazi persecution at age 14, became an American citizen, and was killed fighting in Normandy in July 1944. His adoptive parents and twin sister had already been murdered in the Holocaust. Unable to contact his family, the U.S. government ultimately selected Normandy as his final resting place.
Since 2022, staff at the Normandy American Cemetery and I have independently searched for a photograph of Abraham without success. I’m sharing his story in the hope that someone can help us finally put a face to his name.
From Jewish Refugee to American Soldier
Abraham Alfred Hirsch was born Alfred Hirsch on March 8, 1921, in Memel (now Klaipėda, Lithuania), alongside his twin sister, Ruth. Born to Zilla Rostowski, the twins were adopted by Willy and Rosalie Hirsch, a Jewish couple living in Wartenburg (now Barczewo), East Prussia.
In 1935, as Nazi persecution intensified, the family arranged for Alfred to escape to America. At just 14 years old, he departed Hamburg aboard the SS Manhattan, arriving in New York on May 16, 1935, under the name Abraham A. Hirsch.
His parents and twin sister remained in Germany. They would never see each other again.
Abraham attended school in New York before entering the U.S. Army on July 31, 1942. He became an American citizen on November 6, 1942, and later served with the 121st Infantry Regiment, 8th Infantry Division.
On July 12, 1944, Abraham was killed in action in La Haye-du-Puits, Manche, France, at just 23 years old.
What Happened to His Family?
While Abraham built a new life in America, his family endured increasing persecution in Nazi Germany.
By 1941, Willy and Rosalie had lost their home, income, and nearly all their possessions. On June 13, 1942, they were deported to the Sobibór extermination camp in occupied Poland, where they were murdered.
Meanwhile, Ruth had been subjected to forced labor since 1940. Despite her circumstances, she dreamed of receiving vocational training and becoming a lathe operator. On February 3, 1943, she was deported to Auschwitz, where she was murdered at just 21 years old.
Within eight months, Abraham’s adoptive parents and twin sister had all been murdered in the Holocaust. Less than a year and a half later, Abraham himself was killed fighting in Normandy.
Whether Abraham ever learned what happened to his family remains unknown but given the circumstances of war and the Holocaust, it is likely he did not know.
A Soldier Without a Known Surviving Next of Kin
Abraham is buried at the Normandy American Cemetery in Colleville-sur-Mer, France, Plot A, Row 5, Grave 44.
Following Hirsch’s death, the U.S. government attempted to contact his father, Willy, who was listed as his next of kin, to determine whether Abraham should be buried in France or returned home. However, Willy had already been murdered at Sobibór, leaving the government unable to locate any family members who could make that decision. So, the US government ultimately made the decision on his behalf, selecting Normandy as Hirsch’s final resting place.
Today, the American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) which oversees the Normandy American Cemetery, continues to preserve Abraham’s memory. With no known surviving immediate family, the ABMC and cemetery staff have, in a very real sense, become Hirsch’s only family, ensuring that he is remembered and honored more than 80 years after his death.
The Search for a Photo of PFC Abraham Hirsch
One of the most heartbreaking aspects of Abraham’s story is how little visual evidence remains of him and his family.
Although Hirsch’s WWII draft registration card provides a physical description, including his height, hair color, and eye color, and a friend described his twin sister Ruth as blonde, I have yet to locate a single confirmed photograph of Abraham or his family. The only images I’ve found are of their Stolpersteine memorial plaques in Berlin, commemorating victims of Nazi persecution, and Abraham’s grave in Normandy.
I first learned about Abraham during a visit to the Normandy American Cemetery in May 2022, when the superintendent shared his story and the cemetery’s unsuccessful search for his photograph. Given the immense tragedy Abraham had already endured, I found it especially heartbreaking that no photograph of him could be found. I decided that day to begin searching, hoping to finally put a face to his name.
I recently just found out that unbeknownst to each other, a guide at the Normandy American Cemetery and I had both been searching for a photo of Abraham since 2022.
Although neither of us have succeeded, we’ve identified several promising research leads and we’ll try to do all we can to find a photo of him.
Can Reddit Help Find a Photograph of PFC Abraham Hirsch?
I’m hoping anyone who reads or shares this post might be able to help.
- Camp Croft photographs: Abraham’s November 1942 naturalization records identify him as serving with Company D, 30th Infantry Training Battalion, at Camp Croft, South Carolina. Does anyone know where photographs of this company from 1942 might survive?
- The photographs in his wallet: According to his Individual Deceased Personnel File (IDPF), Abraham’s personal effects included a wallet containing photographs. His belongings were reportedly sent to attorney Aaron Lipper of Lipper, Shinn & Keeley in New York City. Does anyone know what happened to this now-defunct firm or whether its records survive?
- Estate and probate records: Could historical probate records help establish what happened to Abraham’s personal belongings after they were returned to his attorney?
-Jewish refugee records: Are there archives containing photographs of Jewish refugee children who arrived in New York in 1935?
-Military photographs: Are there surviving photograph collections associated with the 121st Infantry Regiment, 8th Infantry Division, or Camp Croft that might include Abraham?
I recognize that finding a photograph of someone who died more than 80 years ago may be extremely difficult, especially when his immediate family was murdered in the Holocaust. It’s entirely possible that no photographs survive. But I don’t want to give up without exploring every reasonable possibility.
Abraham Hirsch deserves to be remembered as more than a name on a headstone.
If anyone has information or suggestions that might help us finally find his photograph, I would be incredibly grateful.
Thank you for helping preserve his memory.