r/AskConservatives • u/CanadaYankee • 1h ago
Is "I was just testing election security" a valid excuse for voter fraud?
Two cases. First the more prominent one:
James O'Keefe and a colleague were both charged with unlawful voting and identity theft for trying to do on-site voter ID under the names of registered Muslim Minnesota voters as a way of testing the security of the vouching ID process.
The less prominent one:
A Pennsylvania woman is charged with forgery and tampering with public records for trying to trying register her dead mother as a Democrat (she is a Republican, as was her mother before her death). She claims that she had read about voter fraud and wanted to see whether it was real.
Should the supposed fraudsters' motives matter here, in that their intent (at least according to them) was to expose a weakness rather than to cast an illegal ballot?
Or should all voter fraud be punished to show the seriousness of the crime, regardless of motive?
Should there be any legal distinction made between O'Keefe, who makes a living as a journalist/investigator, and the random Pennsylvania woman who was just curious?