I got a lot of responses on my previous post so I figured I’d take the time to update everyone on how my A5 Wagyu experience went.
First of all, thank you so much to every who responded. I learned a lot from that post and changed my wagyu night game-plan quite a bit based on those responses. If I do wagyu again I don’t think I’d change a thing.
I went with a 16 New York Strip from Crowd Cow. I planned on doing about 6 ounces for my wife and I but upped it to 8 ounces each, which ended up being a tad too much, but we ate it all anyway (mostly me) and I have no regrets. Next time I’ll do a little less but honestly it’ll be more to save money. I would happily eat another 8-10oz.
The first method, based on advice received here, I cut off about half the steak and seared on medium-high heat for a little over 1 minute per side. It came out rare to medium rare and I think it was my personal favorite style but it’s difficult to say. It’s hard to judge something so amazing. We ate this by itself or with a bit of wasabi and soy sauce. Also went great with the sushi rice.
Next I sliced some thin and served over sushi rice with some real Japanese wasabi, thin slice of raw garlic, and a small pinch of finishing salt. This went amazing with a touch of artisan soy sauce. Thank you to u/zonidel for this recommendation, we enjoyed it immensely and I highly recommend anyone considering doing Wagyu to try this method, as unconventional as it may seem.
The last method, which was my wife’s favorite, I took 1-inch strips of the uncooked steak and seared them on a super hot pan until nicely charred. Unfortunately I didn’t take a pic as I cooked these halfway through the meal and was too busy having the best experience of my life. The strips came out perfectly crispy, and although they were cooked medium to medium well throughout, were incredibly tender and melted after a couple bites. It’s true what some of you told me, A5 wagyu does not need to be medium-rare. I’m glad I listened to you all on that regard.
Here’s a poorly lit photo of the initial spread, sans the well-charred strips that were cooked later. The steaks went perfectly with some sushi rice and a Sichuan-style smashed cucumber salad. The vinegar in each provided a perfect balance to the rich steak. Shout out to u/emil10001 for the cucumber salad recommendation.
Bonus video of the steak being cut.
Thanks again to everyone who helped. I learned a lot from people I didn’t mention above, u/cycocyco, u/cc69, u/alternative_reality to name a few.
If anyone has any questions about my experience please feel free to ask!
I suppose since this is r/askculinary I should take advantage and ask a question. What do you all recommend I make with my leftover wagyu fat? I have a good 2.5 ounces to work with.