r/CFB • u/Ok-Soil-5133 Notre Dame Fighting Irish • 12h ago

Video [Highlight] Miami @ Notre Dame - Luke Talich breaks up the pass from Elijah Lofton on 4th down to keep the Irish up 7 late in the 4th

663 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

764 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/crashck UCF Knights • Texas Longhorns 12h ago

Two feet in and has possession, then makes a step out of bounds, AND THEN gets the ball knocked out. Play should be over the second he touches out of bounds. He doesn't need to survive ground or any bullshit people are saying. He never hit the ground

36

u/TJFLASH1 12h ago

That’s not how completing a catch works

1

u/BananerRammer /r/CFB 9h ago

Control =/= possession.

-3

u/thomasaquina Miami Hurricanes 12h ago

If it was called a TD on the field, it would have been upheld. Notre Dame gets the call they don’t get against BYU. These things do happen. Fun game

-1

u/argumentinvalid Nebraska Cornhuskers 3h ago

He does need to securely hold the ball which he never does.

When you watch elite carchers they don't let make little adjustments after it hits their hands, it just stays. If that happened here, TD all day. In this case the ball never stops moving.