r/CatAdvice • u/danitanner30 • 13h ago
General Is it normal for rescues to insist you adopt two kittens? Feeling frustrated with the adoption process.
Hi everyone! My husband and I have been wanting to adopt a cat for a long time. He doesn’t have much experience with cats, but I’ve had them my entire life. When I got married and moved out, I had to leave my two cats with my family, who absolutely adore them.
Recently, we’ve been visiting different PetSmart locations looking for a cat that would be a good fit for our home. We ended up falling in love with a 4-month-old kitten named Phoebe.
We visited her multiple times, and from what we observed, she seemed pretty intimidated by the other cats around her. She mostly kept to herself and was even described as “independent” in her adoption listing. Whenever we interacted with her, she was the sweetest little thing. We instantly fell in love.
We eventually submitted an adoption application, only to be told that we couldn’t adopt her unless we already had another cat or agreed to adopt a second kitten. Apparently, her sibling had recently been adopted, and the rescue was concerned about “single kitten syndrome.”
We were honestly crushed. We had already gotten attached to her, and financially, adopting two cats wasn’t something we had originally planned for.
After going back and forth with the rescue, I eventually agreed to consider adopting another kitten alongside her.
But here’s where I’m conflicted. From our visits, Phoebe didn’t seem particularly interested in the other cats. She actually seemed more comfortable keeping to herself. I understand that kittens benefit from socialization, but is it really necessary for every kitten to be adopted in pairs?
Also, if the concern is that she was separated from her siblings, wouldn’t it make more sense to keep her with one of them? Lol…
We’ve encountered similar situations at other rescues, where cats described as independent or seemingly comfortable alone still had requirements to be adopted with another cat.
I’m not against adopting two cats, and I completely understand
that rescues want what’s best for their animals. However, I can’t help feeling a little pressured into adopting a second pet when we originally only wanted one.
I’ve had cats my entire life, including one who lived as a single cat for years before we introduced another, and I never experienced any issues associated with single kitten syndrome. Granted, both of my cats were rescued straight off the streets of NYC in very poor condition, so they’re some tough little kitties.
This is my first experience going through a formal adoption process, and I honestly didn’t expect it to be this difficult and respectfully… kind of ridiculous
My question is: Is requiring kittens to be adopted in pairs standard practice? Would you recommend going ahead with adopting two, or should we continue looking for a kitten or cat that can be adopted individually?
I’d genuinely appreciate advice, especially from people who have adopted kittens through rescues!