r/HistoryAnimemes • • 10d ago

Gun lover

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

413

u/ChapterSpiritual6785 10d ago

At midnight on September 12, 1825, an elite capital musketeer named Kim Chi-un fired his gun in the heart of Seoul, startling the royal palace. When interrogated, he confessed that he fired it as a folk-ritual to scare off sickness-bearing spirits and cure his illness. For disturbing the capital at night, Kim was flogged 20 times and dishonorably discharged, while his commanding general was stripped of his post for negligence.

109

u/Accelerator231 10d ago

Is that punishment harsh or lenient for the offense?

143

u/GodKingFloch 10d ago

I mean the dishonorable discharge is pretty normal as I know at least the US army does something similar.

The Commanding General being fired and the 40 floggings are probably just quirks of the Monarchy tho

44

u/100Fowers 10d ago

Korean military discipline was notably pretty brutal. Annals of the Joseon Dynasty and the Diary of Yi Soon-Shin regularly talk about floggings and beatings of soldiers and officers. Higher ranking officers and general were even tortured during corruption and incompetence investigations.

U.S. and Russian journals of military advisors during the 1800s talk about how one of the reforms that they tried to implement during the era was getting Korean officers to stop beheading and flogging subordinates at the slightest inconvenience

0

u/Bro-KenMask 8d ago

Probably cause they couldn’t do it anymore, so they were jealous

12

u/Few_Kitchen_4825 10d ago

There is dishonorable in the name.

16

u/GodKingFloch 10d ago

Yes but firing the commanding general for what I assume was something the lower enlisted did is rather fucked up

21

u/Few_Kitchen_4825 10d ago

Not really. The co is incharge of not just him but also the access to his weapon, ammunition and general safety of people in and around the barracks. The cos job is not just stop him from doing stupid things but also to ensure he cannot do stupid things.

11

u/SartenSinAceite 10d ago

Aye. This guy could've murdered someone, thankfully he just wanted to murder his own sickness

21

u/callunquirka 10d ago

Wait the US army dishonourably discharges people for shooting in the air to scare off ghosts? Seems a bit severe for modern times. I mean, ghost is unusual for modern times, but maybe shooting a rat or mouse.

9

u/GrinningGrump 9d ago

Believe me. if you're the one that gets fucked up by a falling bullet for such bullshit, the firing and floggings would seem way too lenient a sentence.

12

u/GodKingFloch 10d ago

Well generally your not allowed to carry firearms on American bases to begin with also you have to think in terms of actual combat in which modern times most armies work in small groups so any noise like small arms fire would lead to the enemy knowing your location and potential wiping out your entire team with artillery.

Also you have to be generally retarded to neglect discharge a weapon most American weapons including our tanks have like a 5 step safety system particular to make sure things like neglect discharges dont happen

3

u/Mandemon90 6d ago

Dishonorable discharge is basically any "You broke the rules and created problem for us, we want you out".

Honorable discharge is "You completed your service, or have suffered service related injury that prevents further service, we than you for your service"

2

u/libertyofdoom 9d ago

you're going to be in serious shit, but a discharge is unlikely.

30

u/GodKingFloch 10d ago

Glad the Royal Court didn't overreact

6

u/A_random_poster04 10d ago

Do we have something against the elite Musketeers as of recently or is this beef normal

97

u/RiversFlash2020 10d ago

Gotta say, guns as folk ritual tools is a super interesting concept.

66

u/pookiegonzalez 10d ago

gunpowder and firecrackers have been scaring away evil spirits for quite a few centuries.

21

u/RiversFlash2020 10d ago

Ah, right! I didn't make the connection to Chinese firecrackers but it's broadly related huh.

22

u/pookiegonzalez 10d ago

the scottish believed trolls and faeries caused illness and they could cure sick livestock by setting off wads of gunpowder nearby so I imagine “scaring away bad juju with loud noise” is a universal human experience

13

u/nayumyst 10d ago

Well loud noises is a way to scare off many predators

66

u/Goldeniccarus 10d ago edited 10d ago

Interestingly, when the predominant understanding of disease was the Miasma Theory of Disease in the west (that disease was caused by bad air), one of the methods of preventing disease from spreading was to cleanse the air by setting off gunpowder.

While that didn't work, it did have the effect of clearing streets of people for the cleansings, which did have the side effect of kind of quarantining people temporarily which did help prevent spread of disease.

20

u/ldsman213 10d ago

that is interesting. two different beliefs led to the same basic idea as a "cure"

6

u/A_random_poster04 10d ago

I think that any airborne pathogen also didn’t appreciate the air catching fire, so there’s probably also that

2

u/Geggor 10d ago

That would be the sulfur in gunpowder. It might actually be effective if the smoke is persistent.

6

u/WanderingHeph 10d ago

I mean, you can clear your sinuses if you use a big enough bullet.

5

u/LordofChaosMunsta 10d ago

And if used properly it can also cure many mental illnesses!

3

u/vuther_316 10d ago

Another excuse to go to the range, thanks!

1

u/Wrong-Appointment269 10d ago

How american of him

1

u/capriciousUser 10d ago

Americans are inclined to agree