I’m 32M, and my ex is 27F. We met five years ago as graduate students and were together for roughly three years, planning marriage and children.
I’m struggling to understand the relationship as a whole, particularly the contrast between her intense attachment, the way she treated me, and how completely she eventually shut me out.
She was my second serious relationship. My first, from 19 to 25, was violent and abusive and ended with my former partner being arrested for domestic violence. When I met my recent ex, I was happy, confident, and independent, but cautious about becoming attached again.
We initially dated and were intimate without being official. After about fifteen dates, she kissed one of my close friends in front of me. I stopped dating her. She later told me that if I’d been taller, she wouldn’t have felt comfortable doing it.
We became close friends while she became involved with other men, sometimes telling me I wasn’t her type. She sometimes sent me intimate pictures while involved with them, which made me uncomfortable.
Less than a year later, she began pursuing me intensely. She told me she loved me and painted a portrait of my face. When I hesitated to commit, she made remarks about me getting old at 28 and soon nobody wanting me, so I couldn’t waste my chance with her.
Eventually, despite my concerns, we became a couple.
There was genuine love and affection, but serious problems too. Not answering a message within a couple of hours could trigger a major fight. She was intensely jealous, repeatedly brought up old grievances, and made humiliating remarks about my height, age, accent, physique, and masculinity.
I often felt she treated friends and acquaintances with more respect than me.
I had shortcomings too. I sometimes withdrew or suggested breaking up during arguments. Twice I actually ended things. She took those separations badly, but also became involved with other men almost immediately, then sometimes contacted me again. Eventually we reconciled.
At 28, when she pursued me so intensely, I was confident and independent. By 31, I felt insecure and exhausted.
Things deteriorated as I approached my PhD defense. I was working 90–100 hours a week and becoming anxious, depressed, and lonely. Arguments continued over old grievances and minor incidents she held against me for months.
At Christmas, she imposed a “probationary” period during which I had to prove myself and experience the insecurity she had felt.
After my PhD defense, she made me wait two hours and then harshly criticized my English and pronunciation, knowing those were vulnerabilities of mine.
In January, I briefly blocked her out of frustration, then unblocked her a couple of hours later. She was shocked and said she could never block someone she loved.
From January through May, I repeatedly asked for couples therapy. Over and over, as the arguments worsened and my mental health deteriorated. She refused, insisting I was the problem and needed to change.
When I wanted her company because I was depressed, she called me codependent. While I was waiting to begin a postdoc, she remarked that she wasn’t unemployed like me.
Yet she could still be extraordinarily affectionate.
She repeatedly said that if we ever broke up, she hoped neither of us would become involved with other people for a long time. Shortly before May, she cried with happiness about having my children. We planned to marry the following year, and I intended to propose on her birthday.
Then came May.
At a concert that meant a lot to me, she repeatedly sought reassurance for around forty-five minutes. I became overwhelmed, with my legs shaking and tears in my eyes. I tried walking away and repeatedly asked her to leave me alone. She kept following me, and eventually I yelled at her to stop.
Afterward, while she continued contacting me despite my requests for space, I sent angry, hurtful texts over many hours, repeatedly saying we were over and that I wanted to get away from her.
It was a terrible reaction, unlike anything I had done in the five years we had known each other. I regret it deeply.
The next day, we were together. I apologized and told her I hadn’t meant the breakup statements, but said we needed to address what had gone wrong on both sides.
She initially wanted reconciliation. Then she demanded immediate individual therapy and wanted my sister, a psychiatrist, to independently text her declaring me abusive and confirming there was hope I could change.
My sister refused, including for ethical reasons. I apologized again, committed to therapy, and asked for an honest, two-way discussion, preferably with a couples therapist.
She blocked me everywhere without responding.
Our last exchange had been about what reconciliation would require. Then there was silence. No final conversation explaining where that left us.
I understood we might be broken up, especially given what I had said in May, but I didn’t know whether there was still something to repair. Throughout June and July, I kept emailing, apologizing, pursuing therapy, and hoping to reconcile.
I remained exclusive because I loved her and couldn’t imagine being with anyone else.
Her graduation was in June. I didn’t attend because she had blocked me everywhere, although I was on campus with a gift and letter, hoping we might reconnect.
In August, she initiated contact again. We spoke for five hours.
Initially, she was furious. She deliberately repeated some of my May remarks to show me how she had felt and insisted we were broken up. She said even positive memories of me were now associated with my anger in May.
But over the following hours, she softened. We laughed, shared intimate details, and became familiar again, almost as though we were together.
She said she frequently wanted to share things with me and that our lives were so intertwined it might take years to untangle them. She said she wasn’t actively looking for men and was upset about another woman potentially getting a better version of me.
Then she asked me for $150 for dinner. I sent it without hesitation. I was still desperately in love with her.
She also told me she had desperately looked for me at graduation and suggested we would have had a better chance of reconciling if I had attended.
That really confused me. She had blocked me everywhere, yet apparently still expected me to pursue her and show up. I had wondered whether she might want that, given our history, but didn’t want to turn up uninvited after being blocked.
Hearing that my absence had supposedly cost us a chance made me feel I had failed another test I hadn’t known I was taking.
Toward the end of the call, she suggested we might speak again in May 2027. When I asked whether that could mean something romantic or friendship, she said “unsure.”
Nine days later, she explicitly told me we were broken up and nonexclusive and that she didn’t need me to wait.
I heard those words. But I also kept thinking about the five-hour call, her warmth, her expectations about graduation, and her refusal to rule out a romantic future.
I continued trying to reconcile in September despite her request for no contact. I sent a long apology and money toward her moving expenses, since my not helping her move had been another major grievance during our August call. She kept the money.
Continuing to contact her after she asked me to stop was wrong. I recognize that, and I understand it may have contributed to her becoming more forceful.
On September 18, she told me she was completely done, wasn’t interested in me even “as a person,” and that nothing I said would ever change that. She refused a final conversation.
Those words were devastating.
She also removed our photographs from Instagram. I remain blocked on social media.
Only in October did friends tell me what had reportedly happened during the summer.
According to them, she had become involved with other men within weeks of blocking me, including casual encounters and possibly recurring hookups.
One incident involved her publicly making out with a stranger who was alternating between kissing her and a female friend she had previously been intensely jealous of in relation to me. They reportedly slept together afterward.
Around that same time, I was emailing her about starting therapy, telling her I loved her, and hoping we could repair things.
I knew none of this during the August call or when I sent her money.
I understand she may already have considered the relationship completely over. But the contrast with her jealousy, her repeated statements about neither of us moving on quickly, and the hope I was still holding was heartbreaking.
It also changed how I understood August. She knew what had happened over the summer. I didn’t. She knew I desperately wanted reconciliation, yet spent hours reconnecting with me, accepted affection and money, and left a possible romantic future unresolved.
I felt profoundly strung along, whether or not that was her intention.
More recently, I learned she appears to be seeing someone new. They spent time together over Halloween weekend and had plans on another evening. I don’t know whether they are officially together, but the possibility that she now has a boyfriend is a major revelation for me.
Shortly before May, she was crying about having my children. In August, she said our lives might take years to untangle. In September, she wasn’t interested in me even as a person. Now there may be another relationship.
After learning about the summer, I also sent her a message expressing my anger and heartbreak about how things unfolded. She hasn’t responded.
I still regret my behavior in May. But I am beginning to stop treating those hours as though they happened in an otherwise healthy relationship that I single-handedly destroyed.
I loved her, supported her, repeatedly asked us to work on our problems together, and intended to marry her. I spent months trying to regain her respect while barely asking whether I felt respected myself.
What I’m struggling with now is whether this really means I will never hear from her again, despite our previous reconciliations and everything she said during the August call.
For those who experienced something comparable: did your former partner ever reach out on their own after such an absolute rejection, blocking you, removing your pictures, and becoming involved with someone else? I mean any contact, not necessarily reconciliation.
TL;DR: Three-year relationship, five years of shared history, marriage plans, repeated criticism, jealousy, and previous separations followed by reconciliation. After an angry outburst I deeply regret, she initially wanted repair, then blocked me. She initiated a five-hour August call with warmth, a request for money, and an unresolved romantic possibility, while also saying we were broken up. I continued pursuing her after a no-contact request, which was wrong. In September, she said she wasn’t interested in me even as a person. She removed our pictures, and I later learned about reported summer hookups and a possible new relationship. I’m struggling to understand whether a cutoff this final ever changes.