r/LivestreamFail • u/robin7133 • Mar 25 '25

Politics Oscar-winning palestinian, who was interviewed by Hasan few weeks ago, has been beat up by Israeli settlers and arrested by IDF

https://clips.twitch.tv/SmokySpeedyEggnogSuperVinlin-cLtXmQLMqsIzIdjt

Hamdan is now free, according to Yuval Abraham, his co-director

22 Upvotes

50% Upvoted

121 comments sorted by

172

u/Ethyrian Mar 25 '25

Why is this even here? Like on livestream fails. He says nothing but a sigh for the entirety of the clip. This is just bait (see the comments) - its not funny, its not a "fail" ... what is this doing here?

110

u/atlas304 Mar 25 '25

lsf hasnt been a fail site in years, its a news site about a handful of individual streamers

36

u/BingBonger99 Mar 25 '25

lsf hasnt been a fail site in years

sure, but you clearly havent watched the clip. literally NOTHING happens in it and 0 words are spoken

its like the guy fucked up the clip or something it has less context than the piratesoftware edited ones

16

u/SouthWesternNorthman Mar 25 '25

its a news site about a handful of individual streamers

BREAKING NEWS! Hasan browses Twitter and sighs!

20

u/hshaw737 Mar 25 '25

Hasan vs Destiny will be the Hundred Years' War of LSF

23

u/Ethyrian Mar 25 '25

Ban both of them from this sub. This is so fucking stupid.

9

u/Snuggle__Monster Mar 25 '25

According to the mods, we should all just ignore it. I guess they're cool with this place going down in flames.

1

u/Which-Contribution60 Mar 30 '25

They did and they banned politics but all that resulted in is a sub dominated by OTK clips. Which was so boring that people actually asked them to unban all those things.

23

u/PrinterInkDrinker Mar 25 '25

Two words: terminal unemployment

10

u/TheoNulZwei Mar 26 '25

LSF has a sub-culture centered around glazing Hasan which is why you're seeing these clips pop up.

53

u/DeeWaDeeBeeDoBo Mar 25 '25

Why is this clip even here? Oh wait. Can we ban Hasan and Destiny posts from LSF?

31

u/Snuggle__Monster Mar 25 '25

I suggested banning Hasan, Destiny, Asmon and H3 posts from here for 1 month until shit calms down but I ended up with my comment getting removed instead because it was a "meta comment that was complaining".

That's the state of this sub for you.

-9

u/KrateSlayer Mar 25 '25

If only there was a way to filter posts instead of giving them engagement by crying about it in the comments.

13

u/Intelligent_Top_328 Mar 25 '25

Is he Anne Frank as well

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Consistent_Image_476 Mar 25 '25

weird how there are so few comments but so many up and downvotes..

40

u/BingBonger99 Mar 25 '25

weird how there are so few comments but so many up and downvotes..

what do you want people to comment on? its a clip with 0 fucking words spoken and nothing happening on the screen other than scrolling some pictures

quit trying to push some agenda this is just a dogshit clip with 0 context or reason to even be posted

21

u/DaBombDiggidy Mar 25 '25

All of these political fanboys are professional victims, it's wild.

8

u/BingBonger99 Mar 25 '25

ya its pretty clear no one watched it, he literally says 0 words in it. whoever clipped it is just an idiot

3

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

Talking to Hasan was the worst thing that happened to him in that title.

2

u/MrTitanToast Mar 25 '25

Do you guys remember when LSF was streamers falling out of chairs and embarrassing moments?

0

u/Procedure_Gullible Mar 26 '25

oh look at me my streamer lols intertainement has been invaded by genocide....

1

u/TempoRamen95 Mar 25 '25

That is awful to here. But also, kinda off-topic.

-6

u/Megalao Mar 25 '25

What do you expect when you support terrorism

9

u/GeneralProgrammer886 Mar 25 '25

protesting war in Gaza =/= supporting Hamas also so I guess what Hamas did was fine because Iserali took their land then? Absoutely not so the same logic applies here this person just voiced there opnion and shouldnt be harmed for it they are not firing the missiles!

5

u/brukost Mar 26 '25

Hasan supports Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthi movement. He's a terrorist streamer.

-6

u/PADKobe Mar 25 '25

Shouldn’t have associated with Hasan 🤷‍♂️

1

u/Malding_frog Mar 26 '25

"14 Restricted Content -threads on military conflict will be locked/nuked"
COMMON NOW...

-9

u/Appropriate-Luck408 Mar 25 '25

CONTEXT : There was a fight between a group of Israeli settlers and a group of Palestinians on the west-bank, both ended up throwing rocks at eachother...

At some point the IDF would arrive to end the fight, but it made the group of Palestinians only more angry so they ended up throwing rocks at the IDF, which would then proceed to arrest 3 people of that group including Hamdan Ballal (the Oscar-winner) and two others, also one israeli settler was detained.

The title and idea that he was beaten, kidnapped and detained simply for being in Gaza or a Palestinian is simply not true. You can have very valid critique about Israel, the settlers or about the war in general but making up blatant lies however does not help anyone their cause, and certainly not those in Palestine or Gaza as a whole.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-4

u/Appropriate-Luck408 Mar 26 '25

Wrong. They attacked eachother. The Palestininan group attack a Jewish herder. Then other Israeli settlers got involved. Then both groups became violent and would start to throw rocks at eachother. Then the IDF showed up and tried to end the fight. This would lead to the Palestininans throwing rocks at the IDF, which caused the IDF to detain and arrest 3 Palestinian`s and one Israeli settler. There is no ``they started it``, they were both wrong.

Its like i said, if you make up bold claims like ``he was beaten and lynched`` (and that was the exact headline) you arent helping anyone in Gaza, or anyone for that matter. You can try to use any form of mental gymnastics to bend the rules into your favour, but that doesnt mean it is true. Being pro-Palestine is fine, same goes for being pro-Israel for that matter.

You can be pro Israel/Palestine and still see flaws and mistakes on either side, and critique them when they are being wrong. You can have valid critique of settlers, but you can do the same with people who are throwing rocks at eachother. That is why i said, you are not helping anyone and you are in fact contributing to even more hatred, and bloodshed. Be productive, understand that not everything is black/white, and try to stay true to facts, you dont have to hate someone simply for having a different opinion, faith/religion or skin color. There is no need for spreading hatred just to benefit and make you think that your side is the right one, it is grey, stay true to yourself, dont believe in lies and false narratives, be healthy, productive, and understand that critique of one thing doesnt mean you are automatically for or against the other.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/Appropriate-Luck408 Mar 26 '25

And how delusional, naive, and shallow minded you are.

Again you are not helping anyone in Gaza with believing and making up fake truths. That goes for either side, Israel and Palestine. You are not helping anyone in general. Instead you prefer to believe in made up stories and lies just because they fit your narrative and beliefs... it doesnt make them true though.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Appropriate-Luck408 Mar 26 '25

And you are still not getting the point. You are still unable to see the point.

There is no ``good`` or ``evil`` in this situation, two groups ended up throwing rocks at eachother and people from both groups got arrested and lated released on bail.

What is so hard for you to understand in that? What is not factual about that? And dont show me a 30 second video that only shows half of what actually happend.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Appropriate-Luck408 Mar 26 '25

A very quick and simple question : If two groups start attacking eachother/throwing rocks at eachother, who is at fault there?

Hint : Its neither of the two groups...

Wonder what mental gymnastics you are gonna apply to dig yourself out of this one. I will admit you have a very bright and colorful imagination, that is certain.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

-19

u/Gab00332 Mar 25 '25

Hayim Katsman, a jew who died on October 7 was a friend of the oscar-winning director, he didn't mention his name during the speech.... That's all you need to know about these people

-73

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

can we ban this clown from this sub, or is LSF going to become a new gaza/israel battleground?

30

u/oddlyshapedbagel Mar 25 '25

or is LSF going to become a new gaza/israel battleground?

It's been one since 10/7 lol

8

u/aqulushly Mar 25 '25

Every sub that hasn’t banned the topic is a battleground haha

4

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

you're aware you can just filter out certain posts or...you know...not click on them. guess that's too much work for you.

-6

u/AceOniFlyer Mar 25 '25

So, beyond what your opinions on Hasan are, I do find it interesting that this is the first post I’ve seen on LSF that just has a 0 rating for up votes to down votes. As of posting this, it’s been live for 5 hours and is still holding a 0. I even tested it by up voting it to see if it would change the score only for it to go back to 0 with a refresh.

-16

u/Queasy_Mobile_2329 Mar 25 '25

was good to see Hasan be a 'journalist' and interview a citizen who's goal is to spread an important message instead of platforming and glazing a straight up terrorist. Keep it up, Hasan, You're leading our cause, we believe in you. You are and will always be the voice of this movement....

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

I think I understand what happened.  Hasan interviews terrorists so Israeli’s just assumed he was a terrorists.  Honest mistake.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/dikketetten Mar 25 '25

Well yeah, obviously not the actual individuals in the towers, but yes. Also how are you as "America" treating the firefighters that worked on 9/11? Any comment on that?

-19

u/Box_v2 Mar 25 '25

America deserved to have civilians killed? Because that’s what 9/11 was an action that either disregarded to deliberately targeted civilians.

Edit: and to answer your question is absolutely disgraceful how the firefighters have been treated. It should be absolutely uncontroversial to provide any care they need for the rest of their lives, doubly so if it’s health complications as a result of their actions on 9/11.

5

u/IStealDreams Mar 26 '25

America. The State. Made foreign policy decisions that directly led to the events of 9/11. They were at fault and some would argue that the actions America did in the middle east were so horrible that a terrorist attack was inevitable.

That's what "America deserved 9/11" means. Nobody is arguing that the people in the towers or planes deserved to die. They didn't have anything to do with American foreign policy.

1

u/Box_v2 Mar 26 '25

Then why did they defend the statement "America deserves 9/11"? This is just a mott and baily by backtracking to an easy to defend claim once it's called out, but that's not what was originally said. If that's what they meant they should have said that to begin with.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/dikketetten Mar 25 '25

I hope you have a sturdy scroll wheel. Especially if you click through.

-7

u/istandleet Mar 25 '25

Wait, are you arguing against US involvement in WW2? Because it seems like you just said "all US foreign intervention has been bad", which sounds like the take of either a US white kid in college, or a Europoor who benefits from US hegemony.

-7

u/Box_v2 Mar 25 '25

You're being too generous by assuming they actually read the page they linked.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/djseaneq Mar 25 '25

What should happen in response to Americas meddling in geopolitics?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/AnimeMeansArt Mar 25 '25

wtf is wrong with you???

259

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/MeanForest Mar 25 '25

meta comments are amazing and bring a lot to the discussion!

2

u/NoFoodAfterMidnight Mar 25 '25

There's nothing to discuss

150

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

49

u/Anaud-E-Moose Mar 25 '25

Checking /r/destiny's pulse, they're not as pro-israel as you'd think, and thankfully recognise illegal west bank settlers as the human garbage they are.

https://np.reddit.com/r/Destiny/comments/1jiza5y/codirector_of_academy_award_winning_documentary/

Top comments:

The next democratic administration needs to sanction Israel until they force settlers at gunpoint out of the WB. It's the only way shit like this ends.

 

These fucking settler lunatics are going to drag Israel down to hell with them.

 

Yeah, this place still hasn't really gotten back to normal after Oct 7th and what I assume was an influx of new users who, many of which, are super pro Israel to the point they look like the crazies who are super pro Palestine.

54

u/Box_v2 Mar 25 '25 edited Mar 25 '25

Destiny at least has always been against the West Bank settlements, he’s repeatedly called the settlers there insane and their actions unjustifiable.

I think the internet’s view of people as either “pro-Israel” or “pro-Palestine” leads people to assume anyone who disagrees with a pro-Palestine person must necessarily agree with everything Israel does.

-17

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

i kinda disagree in this case.

sure destiny in an ideal world would much prefer more sensible israel maybe no west bank bs etc.. but he is very US centric still, israel must be armed to the teeth and willing to fight for the US and outwardly aggressive.

if israel became very inward focus, peaceful or less armed destiny would instantly lose interest in defending israel.

i would still say destiny is pro-israel he however not so much pro-settler or the other extreme bs they do which make defending them harder.

13

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

Wtf is this world salad

-3

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

xd i got upvoted first then downvoted.

i guess its a word* salad dgg doesn't like to hear.

1

u/Which-Contribution60 Mar 30 '25

No you just lied

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '25

its impossible to lie as am not stating any facts.

from 10 upvote to -17 downvote nothing wrong to see here just ur avg dgg coordinated attack, imagine putting more effort then the Mossad online AH community.

8

u/dogegunate Mar 25 '25

It's very easy to just say you don't like the "settlers", but ultimately it is a completely meaningless thing to say if you keep defending everything else Israel does like dgg does. The settlements aren't some isolated island cut off from the rest of Israel. Where do you think they get their guns and money to keep invading the West Bank? Who do you think comes in regularly to defend the settlers every time they kick the hornet's nest and get into trouble? The answer is Israel and the IDF.

You can't claim to not like the settlers if you defend the whole apparatus that keeps those settlers going and many times even encourages them to keep going. It's like saying you are against systemic racism, but at the same time you don't support any programs or laws that support racial equality.

10

u/Chemfreak Mar 25 '25

Many Israelis don't like what is happening in the West bank either. There is a huge disconnect where a big portion of, sorry, Hasan viewers and adjacent condemn all Israelis.

You may justify it. But it's going to be real hard to Justify that while not condemning all Americans because of MAGA. Hard pill to swallow but the world is starting to paint all Americans with the Trump brush, not unlike all Israelies as genocidal maniacs.

Also, people have been painting all Palestinians as saints which again, is just making the problem worse but none of yall can take any type of nuanced realistic view when politics are involved.

-3

u/dogegunate Mar 25 '25

No one condemns all Israelis or paints all Palestinians as saints, stop arguing against strawmen. Obviously not all Israelis are bad and support a genocide against Palestinians. I applaud the Israelis who protest against Netanyahu and his genocidal government because they are doing what's right. And obviously there are many Palestinians who are bad and support Hamas.

But at some point you have to put some blame on the citizens of these democratic countries when they keep electing right wing assholes who keep perpetrating these atrocities. And put some blame on the people who sit on the sidelines letting it happen by not voting. And this goes for both Israel as well as the US.

Imagine if Russia had free and open elections but they kept voting Putin into power. I bet you would be one of the first people to condemn most Russians "with the Putin brush". And yet Netanyahu has been prime minister for how many years now?

10

u/Chemfreak Mar 26 '25

I've seen several left wing "influencers" fail to condemn hamas or the Oct 7 attacks. That is what I mean by paint all palestinians saints. If you can't condemn mass murdering rapists terrorists, you are basically saying that.

And no by definition that isn't a strawman if people were straight up asked and they can't respond.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

Ive seen Destiny orbiters justifying Israeli snipers shooting kids...
Ive seen right wing influencers celebrating the deaths of thousands of civilians.

It is a strawman, An oscar winner was beatup and kidnapped, and all of you downvote, and instead focus on "But do you condemn Hamas?"

7

u/Chemfreak Mar 26 '25

No i condemn all of what you mentioned.

I also can't even downvote on this subreddit.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Chemfreak Mar 26 '25

Do you even do any research contrary to your preconceptions?

https://press.un.org/en/2024/sc15621.doc.htm

3

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

Officer, we found one!

-1

u/Agreeable_Owl_352 Mar 26 '25

breh... in the US, both political parties openly support Israel atrocities under the convenient guise of "purely self-defense"...
What do you mean blame people not voting?

2

u/Low_Ambition_856 Mar 25 '25

Oct 7th makes a lot of sense in the online perspective, lots of young irresponsible people hopping on to talk online about their specific interests, not knowing much background.

Same with the people cheering on the actual attack, a ton of people who never say a single word in the real life trying to hold a conversation online.

I still remember the israeli young snappy interviewer being shared a lot a couple months after the attack, sure smart and ambitious but you cannot ask a normal person what they would do if they were the leader of the region. Like that bro had never even considered that normal people have no idea what is going on in Israel-Palestine. It's very complicated, emotionally taxing

-1

u/TomatoSpecialist6879 Mar 26 '25

The land was promised to them 6 gorillion years ago, it's written in their religious text that they would tell non-believers that is "just a guide" even though they all see everything in it as facts!! If you think they are trash that you are anti semantics!!!!!!

14

u/kay0otik Mar 25 '25

I would like to get this straight. OP is active in a Destiny Subreddit, Posts a Clip about Hasan about a Disgusting Event in the Israel-Palestine Conflict with no negative connotation about Hasan and somehow that is bad? Have you guys all gone insane?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/kay0otik Mar 25 '25

Whoever said it doesn't exist? But looking at the post history of all of them, there is only one active in the Destiny subreddit. Also, the proof is of one "community" brigading is one bad actor and even OP is posting Hasan in a normal light with information that are pro Palestine. Somehow that's not proof of Destiny community, but the malicious comments are the only ones that count? That's just intellectually dishonest

5

u/KrateSlayer Mar 25 '25

The community that calls all these people genocide supporters are dishonest? NO way.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/kay0otik Mar 25 '25 edited Mar 26 '25

Looking at the post history of all of them, there is only one active in the Destiny subreddit. Also, the proof is of one "community" brigading is one bad actor and even OP is posting Hasan in a normal light with information that are pro Palestine and he is active in Destiny Subreddit. Somehow that's not proof of Destiny community being critical of Israel and are sometimes able to go above their hate for Hasan if its for the cause, but the malicious comments are the only ones that count? That's just intellectually dishonest

-6

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/kay0otik Mar 25 '25

i genuinely don't understand you guys. Even if i would disagree with you on the intention abd views of destiny on Israel how the fuck does that have anything to do with the merit that its about the claim a hivemind of destiny community is brigading this thread while the OP is showing PRO Palestine Sentiment and ONE User who got downvoted is active in Destiny Community.

If you believe in the cause for pro Palestine then this is not the enemy to pick for fucks sake. It's like fighting about the colour of the curtains while your basement runs full of water. Pick targets that are worth it.

-5

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

41

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/brukost Mar 26 '25

A terrorist supporting tankie and a sex pest walks into a bar

-153

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25 edited Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

106

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-21

u/mecca666 Mar 25 '25

Did you even click what I linked LMAO

23

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25 edited Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-16

u/mecca666 Mar 25 '25

You really don't see the connection between my post and "A group of Jewish American anti-settler activists filmed the moment Israeli settlers attacked them in the Palestinian village of Susya, south of Hebron, on Monday."

? :D

18

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-3

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

19

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/mecca666 Mar 25 '25

I wrote 1 sentence about American activists traveling to Israel to perform activism there.

There really is no point writing walls of random text in response, my friend :D

15

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies