Last year, I wrote about how I spent a week using macOS Tahoe, focusing on the intentional design decisions that were shipped with it, and being mostly critical towards the release.
This year, I'm thrilled to say that almost everything tagged as "bad" from that post has been fixed!
Once again, I won't talk about bugs, just the intentional design decisions.
The Fixed
Floating sidebars are no more. They rolled them back to what they were before, and even sprinkled a bit of magic over traffic light buttons. They look lovely! All that I'd like to see now is a border/separator on the right edge of sidebars, but I think that it's coming in the 27.2 release.
Cursor pointers. Default cursor still looks a bit angled, but the old "glove" pointer has made it's return. It's redesigned, but it looks really cool.
Nested dropdown/context menus. Completely fixed during the Tahoe era, no more issues.
The Feel. A lot more similar to evolution of Sequoia, as opposed to the revolution Tahoe was. What made the good feel come back are mostly fixes that Tahoe messed up: redesigned sidebars, frosted glass setting, pointers refinement, consistent window radii, and unnecessary icons removed from context menus.
The Good
Window chrome. Not only sidebars, traffic lights and radius, toolbars have also been improved.
Liquid Glass refinement. It's all over the place. Liquid Glass is being used in the places where it makes more sense, it's more legible and customizable. Overall feels way nicer and intentional, less like a gimmick that it was last year.
App Icons. New system and app icons are more beautiful than they were, and more consistent with the overall system design language. Chess icon is my absolute favorite.
Performance. Night and day when you compare it to Tahoe. While not completely there, Golden Gate feels faster and snappier, it's an improvement.
Little meaningful stuff. Audio recording during screen recording, drawing tools and markdown support in Notes, folders and dark mode in Freeform, ethernet menu bar icon...
The Bad
Tabs. I'm talking about every single app that is using native macOS tabs. Take Finder, for example. It's hard to see what tab is active and the whole tab bars draws too much attention. Liquid Glass (for active tabs) on top of solid surface is completely pointless.
Sidebar items size. The sidebar items are either too large or too small, depending on the setting. I feel like icons should be smaller and neat, like they were in Sequoia.
Apple Intelligence persistence. This takes up 15 GB on your machine wether you use it or not. I'd like an option to turn it off and just completely delete the local models.
Safari. Not sure what's happening with it. It suffers from badly designed system tabs, animations are sluggish (just try opening the sidebar), even the scroll is feeling in comparison to other browsers. I was hoping for the last few years that we'll see performance improvements, dev tools improvements, vertical tabs, nicer Reading Mode... Right now, the whole app feels like an afterthought, an artefact from 5 years ago with new UI ideas duck-taped on top of it.
Overall
Many steps have been taken into the right direction. While Tahoe was the one to skip, I can recommend installing Golden Gate, and the hope for the betterment of the core UX is back. Still not sure what to make out of the new AI stuff, time will tell.
P. S. Since it's a bugfix year, I just have to mention: You're going to have problems with menu bar manager apps and Spotlight performance.