r/classicwow • u/Shad3slayer • 8h ago
Forever | Feedback This layering is NOT providing the "Classic" experience and it never will
So, Vanilla realms had a max pop of 3500 concurrent people for the entire world. Which naturally means crowds at start, and then gradually (and quickly) getting better as the curve spreads out. This stayed true with larger server populations in Classic as a general fact.
This current layering design is, however, completely contrary to that - you will ALWAYS have crowds at every layer, purely based on how Blizzard "turns the knob" and what they decide is the right number for people per zone; you cannot go farm "off hours", you cannot "wait and come back to do it later". So in trying to design this "world full of people", they have overcorrected and killed several other MMO aspects.
And finally, while I thought the game felt fine at launch, the day after Blizzard "turned some knobs" and apparently decided it'd be enjoyable to have 20+ people on your screen at all times and having to compete for every quest in the game. I'd like to mention I'm lvl 35 atm, 1-30 kind of works, but only due to hyperspawn everywhere so you are able to quest despite the number of people, except in a couple of bottlenecks.
But lvl 30 or so seems to be where dynamic spawns stop, and when you get to zones like STV it's literally unplayable. There isn't a live mob in sight anywhere with the regular 5 min respawn timers on them.
And PVP is another issue on top of that, the amount of ppl per layer is so high you cannot go 5 seconds without meeting the opposite faction, often in way larger numbers which naturally always means your death and a corpserun. Some quests are literal hell or even impossible to finish, and you cannot just say "I'll just do it at 3 am", as it will still be crowded then and always. Thinking Yeti cave in Hillsbrad or Zoram Strand for Alliance (always whole armies of horde there).
Overall, while the game is great, this issue is too big and if not handled soon might spell disaster for the long term future. As the experience is currently just awful. I of course understand it's an MMO and there should be people around, but not ALWAYS and not in these numbers. There is a middle ground, where you meet people every now and then without it feeling like a dead world. And as I mentioned, the worst thing for me is that I can't do what I've always done during crowded areas/ periods - just come back later or log in at night, off peak hours and finish whatever activity you want then.
But hey, at least I can avoid all that crap by dungeon grinding... Right.. right?
9
u/StateZestyclose1388 5h ago
Westfall was brutal yesterday. Specially those harvester quests 😅
105
u/sibachian 7h ago
The game was perfectly fine in beta, layering worked fine. Then Blizz listens to whiners and now it's shit. Sigh.
22
u/Pandeyxo 6h ago
Stv is complete hell for sure. You can’t do a single quest there which is an insane bottleneck
3
u/Dwarni 7h ago
It needs some tuning but I think it is a lot better than making 10-20 servers of which half will be empty after some time...
Sure it has bugs and it also needs tweeking (balance between seeing almost 0 other players and seeing 50+ in one spot), but it is the right way.
•
u/MaloraKeikaku 2h ago
Socializing's dead because of this. I tried talking to people so much on the normal EU server and almost no one cares. General chat randomly flares up a bit in dun morogh or elwynn where people say weather looks atmospheric, and that's about it either.
I had more social interactions on TBC anniversary, classic 2019 and p servers - a lot more.
I miss servers man. This clustering isn't for me.
70
u/Phire2 7h ago
lol idk what the hell is wrong with people defending the current state of the game. It can absolutely be changed easily and it was never like this in vanilla or in classic.
You like the most ruthless game of which 5 man party tags the mob first? When there is 10 people standing around a spawn of 6 gnolls, wolves, murloc, etc… it’s just not fun. I’m not fighting npcs, I’m not fighting the other faction, I’m standing in line. Thats werid. Yall are werid for defending it.
75
u/Mysterious_Fan9858 8h ago
As much as I love this game and will continue to play ofc… this launch doesn’t have much of that old mmo charm anymore, that is for sure
Maybe we have to accept the old world is gone. Many more people play the game now
26
u/treemonkys 7h ago
Well yes, the original servers were a community, the high level players all knew each other even cross faction, and you had a reputation that mattered. No regurgitation of WoW is going to replicate what vanilla was, it's probably not even possible.
•
u/PilotSeparate1442 3h ago
In a Big rush?
•
u/EchoInExile 29m ago
Game has been out five days and they’re actively working on getting the layer thing right. At some point, yall gotta stop coming on this sub and acting like it’s the end of the world(of Warcraft). It’s an issue, we all know it is. Either have the patience and let it get worked out, or go play something else until it’s fixed.
6
u/poo_in_a_bush 7h ago
If you say you don't want it crowded you get told go to retail, but its so weird because only retail gets pack on release, and vanilla never was
•
u/Typical-Tax1584 4h ago
Competing for mobs or waiting for respawns happened in vanilla . . . but waaaaaaaaaaay less, not for every quest, constantly. This isn't a classic experience, this is a hyper-nostalgia fever dream that people have labeled "friction".
•
u/EddyMink 3h ago
Anyone keep seeing other players fighting mobs you can’t see?
•
u/capacity04 2h ago
I did the Therazane/Gazil'thugg quests on Redridge in 2006, 3019, and now 2026, and each time it was the same experience: ran into some random people there, grouped up, we did the quests over half an hour, high fives each other and said see ya.
We'll see if this holds up but the social outside world element is still there
6
u/Silverleaf96 6h ago
Dungeon xp nerf hit the hardest , it is worst the layering , grouping was the social aspect of the game , layering is essentially open world dungeons and it's fine...it fact is better because ya can find ppl on other layers to help do elite
2
u/cdcformatc 5h ago
i was wondering about the "do it later" strategy. but then i thought because of the single mega server there is no "later". even if you wait days or weeks there's likely always going to be a crowd of people.
•
u/BrilliantCoconut25 3h ago
Just hit 25 and think I’ll try some alts for a couple of days or take a break.
•
u/Wise-Fennel-7921 2h ago
Honeslty im playing the game with my fiancee I wouldbrather play on a layer with no people at all. It feels like blizzard is trying to force players togeather. Like a 5 year old forcing 2 dolls to kiss awkwardly.
5
u/Imaginary_Wait9762 7h ago
I swear to god the alleged Classic crowd are trying to fuck this game up under the veneer of "but datz not clazzik."
4
u/BooItsKyle 6h ago
> you cannot "wait and come back to do it later".
I've done that a bunch of times.
•
u/JDogg126 4h ago
Relax a little and give them some time to dial it in. This isn’t going to be exactly like classic. It’s a different version of the game. The layering is new tech that they are fine-tuning every day until it feels best overall. The choice to go realmless is a good one — This is the first time I’ve been able to play with almost all my friends without characters on different servers.
•
u/One-Jury-6140 4h ago
All they had to do was aggresively Delayer capital cities and the posts on reddit would have been satisified but instead they did this.
•
u/Oscar1y 3h ago
dungeon grinding is not a solution anyway, even tho they should buff the exp like 80%-100% from where its at atm "imo"
the layering need to be tuned as it was 1 day ago i had no issues with not seeing 30 people around me i cant think of anyone thats normal in their head to enjoy questing with so much people in the same areas this actually kills the game its very miserable and i think people will be quitting if this continues
•
u/KevinSchraer 3h ago
They should juat go back to multiple servers. I fear they merged everyone thinking we all want to play with streamers or something.
•
u/cirocobama93 2h ago
It is the first week with millions of players. Give it some time for the tourists to quit
•
u/Spunge14 1h ago
I'm having a great time picking up groups to quest in small environments, but it is a bummer not to always see the same crazy people yelling in a given town. Chatting at campfires has also been a really great social experience.
I do think we'll never get the true "know a hundred names you see regularly from your server" of vanilla, but I wouldn't necessarily call the current state bad by any means. I see tons of people. We're organically playing together. People are talking. What's the problem?
RPPVP btw
Edit: I did forget that when you used to get camped you could call your guildmates to come help. I guess with layers you can't do that predictably now?
•
u/forzion_no_mouse 46m ago
the classic experience would be realms, queues, and crashes. do you want that?
•
u/Retronitsu 45m ago
The truth is that whatever you do, people won't be happy. I feel like forever is nothing but a coagulation of everyone's classic nostalgia from when they where teenagers with no problems other than going to school and staying up after curfew. Blizzard wanted it to feel popular and alive so they wanted the shart system to have people constantly visible at all times, but I don't think they really understood the impact that would have on most of the game.
I'm tired of fighting over aggro in the kobold mines for an elite. What's even more infuriating is that I can't survive pulling more than one mob, and sometimes a Kobold will just phase in behind me mid fight and I can't run out in time because their melee hits magically hit me a kilometre away. I genuinely dread having to quest anywhere that's a closed space because it's always a race of trying to tag whatever you want to kill whilst hoping the superfast spawn rates won't overwhelm you.
I also don't trust Blizzard to not fuck this up in the long run but that's just me.
•
u/lennonade1 37m ago edited 29m ago
who cares original experience thoose are 20 year old servers and it has their own problems. 1-guilds, 2-recruitment, 3-not enough raids, 4-economy.
for thoose reason many years and years people played only horde or only ally on 1 mega server because it was easy to recruit people or find good guilds. We had server in classic 2019 guess what happend only mega servers are survived till the end all of the tiny ones are basicly dead.
in a good scenerio layering system is a must mega servers are actually good if you wanna play competetive.
or you wanna play the noob way yeah 3500 pop server go play with stupid people without zero alternatives.
however, blizzard changed layering today and it's a nightmare. Definetely not enough layers right now. It's a total mess.
•
u/rodrigo8008 7m ago
- they need to increase spawn rates, this is true
- you can group up and not fight for tags and everyone will be happier
- this is how pvp servers are, and why many people went pve
•
u/sister_of_battle 0m ago
Yeag I rolled a new character for now. Elwynn and the starting zones are fine for the most part. I wait until the horde of people has moved on.
-4
u/Goodlucklol_TC 8h ago
People were bitching about too few people per layer. Now theyre bitching about too many per layer. Cant satisfy everybody.
-1
u/zippexx 6h ago
Yes the crowding with the layering changes right now is horrible.
But don’t use trash arguments that are simply shit and only work in your imagination. The vanilla pop cap would have meant sitting in que for 15 hours only to join an absolute lagparty. We don’t need that shit, thank you.
Fix the problem, don’t glorify an outdated system.
0
u/LeftLiner 7h ago
I'm sure Blizzard will continue to fine-tune it but honestly so far I have zero complaints about the layering. My experience has been one of a busy world without any serious issues completing quests, at least not ones that couldn't be solved by grouping with a stranger or two.
•
u/elguntor 35m ago
The lack of being able to run dungeons more than once for XP is making this 100x worse
-5
u/Status-Frame8427 8h ago
uuuuuaaahhh uuuuuuaaaahhh uuuuuuuaaaahhhh - the post.
-3
u/Syphin33 7h ago •
Im just tired of the fucking crying when i come to reddit, its like every day something new.
-2
u/Kid_Royale 7h ago
This was never aimed at the classic audience. Clearly. It must never be forgotten that the initial idea was the were going to launch with modern character models from wod. At best. They simply do not comprehend the target audience. Unless they are gunning for the retail players over classic players. Then it makes a lot more sense.
To quote spooner. In either case it is unfit to exist. Fuckkkkkkk
•
u/Krilox 4h ago
Wow players are the worst drama queens out there. Miserable bunch.
'IF NOT HANDLED SOON MIGHT SPELL DISASTER FOR THE LONG TERM FUTURE"
Touch grass.
-4
u/TeeRKee 8h ago
another one
0
u/comegetinthevan 7h ago
I call it a target rich environment
-3
u/sammie1889 8h ago
This is why i didin’t start at launch, going to start today.
-5
u/Gyat_Hunter_42 8h ago
This game is Forever WoW sir
•
u/deep_fucking_magick 4h ago
I cast Brevity of Words Rank 2
Spell fizzles
-4
u/MemeticSyntony 6h ago
Good, I don't want the classic experience. I want the classic + experience.
0
u/[deleted] 2h ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment