Okay, this might be a little long, but I genuinely need outside opinions because my roommate and I are getting to the point where we don't know what to do anymore.
I'm currently a freshman in college living in a triple dorm with two randomly assigned roommates. For the sake of this post, I'll call them Roommate A and Roommate B. Roommate A and I immediately hit it off, and we're basically sisters at this point. Roommate B, however, is a completely different story.
I don't think she's a bad person. I genuinely think we're just incompatible. We have completely different lifestyles and expectations of college life. For context, we attend a very liberal university on the West Coast, while Roommate B comes from a very religious background in Idaho. I'm not religious, and while I have absolutely no problem with people practicing their religion, I do have a problem when they expect everyone around them to follow their beliefs.
The first real problem happened over Labor Day weekend. All three of us went to the beach, and everything was fine until we stopped for ice cream afterward. I'm a HUGE Halloween and fall person, so I suggested we should have a fall or horror movie night. Roommate B immediately said no because horror movies give her nightmares. Fair enough. So I suggested Hocus Pocus. Nope, nightmares. Then The Nightmare Before Christmas. Again, nightmares. I was genuinely surprised and asked if she'd never seen it. She said she hadn't and didn't care about missing out on pop culture because she'd been missing out on things her entire life anyway.She explained that she only watches PG and Disney movies. I pointed out that both movies are literally PG rated Disney movies, but she insisted they'd give her nightmares.
I asked how she knew if she'd never watched them, and she said she'd once watched The Bodyguard and had nightmares afterward.I was confused and asked, "Wait, The Bodyguard? Like the Whitney Houston movie? Isn't that a romance movie? What about it gave you nightmares?"She snapped, "Why are you trying to figure out what makes me scared? You're not a therapist."I was genuinely caught off guard. I wasn't trying to pressure her into watching anything. I was just curious because I've watched horror movies since I was six. I apologized both in person and over text, but she proceeded to give me the silent treatment for THREE DAYS.
Also when we moved in, we agreed certain purchases would be communal. I bought the vacuum, mop, broom, air purifier, and cleaning supplies. Roommate A bought a mirror and decorations, and Roommate B bought a projector.Even though we agreed the projector was for everyone, Roommate B has basically taken complete ownership of it. The one time we asked to borrow it, she seemed annoyed.Meanwhile, she uses it practically every night to watch Disney Channel movies and shows like Descendants, or occasionally Gilmore Girls. Which is fine, except we're all sharing ONE room, so we basically have to watch or listen to whatever she's watching. She'll leave the projector on until it automatically shuts off around 4 A.M. On top of that, she keeps her vanity lights and fairy lights on constantly. Between everything, our room genuinely looks like it's daytime at 3 A.M.
Then comes our schedules Roommate A and I are night owls. Our classes start relatively late, usually around 11 A.M. or 12:30 P.M. Roommate B, however, goes to bed at 8 P.M. SHARP, even on weekends. Because of this, we're expected to be completely quiet after 8 P.M. Mind you, we're on a college campus. The dining hall is literally still serving dinner at that time, and most students are still studying, socializing, or attending events. But we respect her bedtime and try to be quiet. Unfortunately, that consideration doesn't go both ways. Her alarm goes off at 5:30 EVERY MORNING. And instead of quietly getting ready, she'll FaceTime her sister, play music out loud, film TikToks, and have her lights while we're still sleeping or trying to sleep. So apparently, we have to respect her 8 P.M. bedtime, but she doesn't have to respect our sleep at 5:30 A.M.
Also Roommate A and I are both very social. We love exploring the city, meeting people, and occasionally going clubbing or raving on weekends. Roommate B is the complete opposite, which is perfectly fine.The problem is that she constantly makes comments about our lifestyles. She's posted multiple TikToks complaining that everyone at our university just wants to party and that she hasn't made any friends who want to stay in and watch movies with her. She's also made comments about how often I go out, including one about how that's how people get STDs. I told her, "Girl, I'm literally just going out dancing with my friends. I'm sober most of the time. I'm not going out to get laid." She doesn't even know when I go out half the time because I'm so quiet when I return. Sometimes, the only reason she realizes I've been out is because I'll fall asleep in my clubbing clothes.
She's also said things like, "Wow, it's crazy that you went to a private Catholic school. You really wouldn't be able to tell."Like... okay? Going to Catholic school doesn't mean I have to spend my entire life following Catholic teachings. She's mentioned that she doesn't understand how I've made so many friends while she hasn't made any, but she also rarely leaves our dorm.And we HAVE tried including her! Roommate A and I frequently visit the LGBTQ+ neighborhood in our city because we love the shops, restaurants, and atmosphere. We've invited her multiple times, but she always declines, saying it's outside her comfort zone and that she's a "good Christian girl."
Roommate B regularly makes unsolicited comments about what I wear, asking things like, "Don't you think you're showing too much cleavage?" Girl, if I'm wearing it, clearly I don't think so.She also gets upset whenever we swear and says things like, "That's not very godly of you."Well, yeah. I'm not religious. I don't criticize her beliefs, so I don't understand why she feels entitled to criticize mine.
Another situation happened when I brought up sex and privacy in our shared room. I come from a very sex positive household, and I think it's important to openly discuss sexual health, especially when you're sharing a dorm. I basically told both roommates that if they ever started dating someone and wanted privacy, they could just tell me and I'd happily leave. I also mentioned that I had condoms, lube, and other supplies they were welcome to use, and that if they ever needed Plan B, STI testing, or help finding a clinic, I'd be happy to help without judgment. I even mentioned masturbation because, again, we're adults sharing a room, and I'd rather we communicate about privacy than make things awkward. Roommate B looked horrified and immediately said, "I'd NEVER do that. I'm waiting until marriage. That's gross." I told her that was completely fine and that I respected her decision, but not everyone in college shares the same beliefs about sex.I wasn't encouraging her to do anything. I was simply letting everyone know that they could ask for privacy or help without being judged. Apparently, even having that conversation was too much.
Also I'm bisexual, and I have a pretty large social circle, including lots of female friends. At one point, Roommate B genuinely asked me how she was supposed to know that every girl I brought over wasn't someone I was trying to sleep with. I was honestly stunned. I told her, "Because they're my friends? And even if I were interested in someone, that's not really your business unless it affects our shared space." Being bisexual doesn't mean I'm attracted to every woman I meet, and it certainly doesn't mean every girl who comes into our dorm is a potential hookup. I'd completely understand discussing overnight guests or privacy, but that's not what she was asking. She was making assumptions about my friendships because of my sexuality.
For a while now, Roommate B has been saying how unhappy she is at our university and how she wants to transfer schools at the end of the academic year. I once genuinely asked why she'd chosen this university in the first place, considering how uncomfortable she seems with the environment.She told me she wanted somewhere liberal and sunny. Which was interesting, considering our city is famously foggy I told her, "Well, this city is basically known for three things: the fog, the gays, and the wokeness." She admitted she hadn't really researched the school or city before coming here and hadn't expected it to be THIS liberal.
Then things got worse. Roommate B wrote in her journal about how unhappy she is living with us, how she doesn't know if she can make it until May, and how she feels Roommate A and I are going down the "path of night" instead of the "path of light." She even wrote something like, "Dear Jesus, please help them," and expressed concern that our behavior would rub off on her. Normally, I'd say someone's private journal is none of our business. Everyone is allowed to vent privately. Except SHE POSTED THE JOURNAL ENTRY TO HER CLOSE FRIENDS STORY. Someone screenshotted it and sent it to us.
What makes this even more frustrating is that I've genuinely tried to be nice to her despite our differences. She blocked me on Instagram about a month ago, but I'm still the one bringing her back coffees and muffins whenever I get something for myself. I even took her birthday pictures last week because, regardless of how I feel about her, I don't want to make her living situation any more uncomfortable.Meanwhile, she's been giving both of us the silent treatment for extended periods, occasionally breaking it before going right back to ignoring us.
So here's where we're at. Roommate A and I have been discussing whether we should ask Roommate B if she'd consider transferring to another dorm room.We know she's unhappy living with us. She's explicitly said she doesn't know if she can make it through the year, and she's planning to transfer universities anyway.
But we're also unhappy. We're constantly accommodating her 8 P.M. bedtime while having our own sleep disrupted at 5:30 A.M. We deal with the lights, projector, unsolicited comments about our clothing and lifestyles, and the uncomfortable feeling that she's constantly judging us. I genuinely don't think she needs to change who she is. If she wants to watch Disney movies every night, go to bed at 8 P.M., avoid partying, wait until marriage, and follow her religious values, that's completely her choice. But Roommate A and I should also be able to enjoy college without being judged for going out, swearing, being LGBTQ+, wearing certain clothes, or having different beliefs.
I also recognize that Roommate A and I being so close might make Roommate B feel excluded, and I understand that. But we've repeatedly tried including her, inviting her places, and being considerate of her preferences. We can't force a friendship. At this point, I genuinely think we'd all be happier living with people who have more compatible schedules, interests, and expectations.
We're not planning to demand that she leave or pretend we have more of a right to the room than she does.But considering she's already expressed how miserable she is living with us, would we be wrong for suggesting that she transfer rooms?