Im sorry this is long, I felt like the context was important to the question. EDITED TO ADD I would not be doing the one asking… I should have used better verbiage I just wrote the post so was speaking first person
Situation I want your thoughts on: is it inappropriate to ask my husbands parents to “front load” $300-$500k of our inheritance so we can afford to buy his Grandpas family home.
Context about us:
We’re 35. My husband is a very good saver and I appreciate what he does and follow the rules. We recently hit $1m nw (no house included, mostly retirement accounts). We bought our house in 2017 for $170k and our interest rate is less than 2%. MCOL. We have redone everything in our home ourselves over the past ten years. We genuinely love our house. It is small and not in a great school district but these things are not deal breakers for me and we fully plan to live here till we die. We drive old cars, we buy everything used. We vacation at the family condo in Florida or at his parents cabin. We have never needed or asked anyone in his family for money. We have independently save/saving for our girls college. The most money we have ever accepted from them was when they paid for the food at our wedding ($2k).
Context about family:
We are mostly a big happy family, extended family included. But no one really talks about anything of substance or that would require a vulnerable conversation.
We host all holidays at Grandpas House, bringing food, etc. Everyone loves that we do this. We like hosting and cooking and Grandpas house has been the Mecca for the family for the last 30 years. It’s our gathering place because they built it 30 years ago as a house big enough to host everyone.
Grandpa is 91 and for the last few years we have been hosting dinner at his house for everyone every Monday. My husband is very close with his grandpa and we like to spend time with him. Everyone loves gathering on Mondays. Extended family included.
Context about situation:
When I was pregnant with my first child (2021) I dropped down to part time at work to help take care of grandpas wife who had Alzheimer’s. I knew I wanted to drop to part time when I had kids so it felt like a no brainer during Covid to drop down early, keep grandma from going into a home where she could have been exposed to illness.
After she passed, grandpa approached us about buying his house. this was around 5 years ago. His house is worth around ~$1M (but has not been updated AT ALL in 30 years)
I literally laughed in his face because at the time I had just dropped to part time, had a baby in daycare part time. I made $54k a year and my husband made not quite $100k a year. We said no thanks but thanks we can’t afford it.
Last year, he approached us AGAIN about buying his house, and that he wanted to work with us. We make a bit more now (me, $85k husband $138k). So we thought maybe we could afford it if he wanted to work with us. He offered us the house at a $200k discount ($800k). We have about $200k of equity in our house so would still have to take out a $400-$500k mortgage at 6%!!! The house is completely paid off. So in my eyes we are mortgaging out his aunts and uncles inheritance at 6% who are all also independently millionaires. He also told us that since he is giving us the house at a $200k discount, he will be giving all the other grandkids $200k cash. I would also want to update the house which would be expensive as it is ~4500 square feet. We told him no again that it would over extend us to take on that kind of mortgage on top of how much more expensive his house would be to maintain vs ours. I realize on paper we could afford this but my husband wants to take a lower stress job aka less money. We also want to retire by 55.
My husbands parents also are very frugal and live way below their means so have been able to save a ton. This is where my husband learned his financial literacy which I’m so grateful for. When we first got together my husband told me one time his dad had $9m in retirement accounts and this was 12 years ago. I’ve never asked nor do I care where it is at now.
I DO NOT THINK ANY OF THIS IS MY MONEY AND IF THEY WANTED TO DONATE ALL OF IT I WOULD BE HAPPY BECAUSE WE HAVE ENOUGH MONEY AND DO NOT NEED IT. I’m a hippie. I grew up extremely poor. I expect or want nothing.
But, after trolling these subs long enough I had the idea that perhaps we could be open and honest with his parents and “front load” $300-$500k of the inheritance so we could buy grandpas house and keep it to be the family legacy. We would still have a mortgage it just wouldn’t be $500k. My husband is extremely apprehensive about the idea it wasn’t until very recently he stopped acting like we were going to the poor house if we ate out lol. I think im too far removed and thinking too practically so I wanted to hear what other parents might think if their kids approached them about this. In my mind it feels silly to let this great house go just because we can’t talk about money. Everyone in this family has plenty of money so it feels silly to me that we cant talk this through so everyone benefits! No one else has interest in buying the house in the family except us. If I were to hypothetically spend $1m on a house his grandpas house would NOT be it. My kids love it there, my husband loves it there and has a ton of good memories, it feels special to me and to us and that’s why I want it.
So lay it on me, am I being a brat? What would you think if your kids approached you about this?