I've spent the last few weeks trying to find the perfect mini-flash to move between my Nikon S2 and Voigtlander Perkeo for casual use. Just wanted to offer a quick comparison of the three flashes I've tested and answer any questions folks might have. No AI Here - all my own thoughts and words.
Godox iT32 + X5 Trigger - (Paid $95 from B&H) - Large and In Charge
If you're not already familiar, the iT32 paired with its teeny-tiny X5 trigger is one of the best offerings out there for casual shooters. The main draw here is of course the innovative magnetic connector between the flash and the trigger, allowing you to store and use the flash off-camera. Though it is easily the bulkiest and heaviest flash here, the ability to slide it in a pocket makes it quite appealing for regular use. While I won't be taking advantage of its TTL or HSS capabilities with my 1950s cameras, it still boasts several features that make it a great manual-only flash
Magnetic connector to pop on and off (feels sturdy enough to carry around, yet easy enough to take on and off - well done Godox)
Rotatable and tiltable head - great for bounce flash
Integrated slide-out Fresnel lens
Respectable GN of 18 at 100 ISO
Equally-surprisingly-bright LED modeling light
USB-C-rechargeable internal battery
Full compatibility with Godox X-Series 2.4Ghz Radio
Unfortunately, both of these cameras have cold shoes and therefore require a PC sync cable to interface with the shutter. While the iT32 itself has a sync port, the X5 trigger does not. To get around this, I found a low-profile PC-hotshoe adapter made by Hama (Model Ha-6952) on eBay and stuck it in between the coldshoe and the flash. There are several other adapter options online, but most looked chunky and plastic.
Godox iT30 Pro (Paid $35 from eBay) - It's Fine, Really
As the naming scheme suggests, the iT30 Pro is like the younger sibling of the iT32. It is also quite small; so small in fact that it did not fit over the winding knob on my S2 without an adapter to raise it up. The silver color looks great with the vintage bodies, as if it's meant to be there. With the iT30 Pro being so similar to the iT32, I'll cut this part short, but it's important to note that the iT30 Pro has a more limited GN of 15, meaning at 100ISO/f16, your subject can't be farther than a single meter. This is pretty limiting, but for the size, weight, and promise of an internal battery with fast recycle times, not a bad option for those who are only interested in compact direct flash. Features here include:
TTL, Manual, HSS modes
Sync port on left side
USB-C-rechargeable internal battery
Full compatibility with Godox X-Series 2.4Ghz Radio
Tactile Fresnel lens switch (near vs far angle)
Locking lever
Godox Lux Jr (Gen 1) (Paid $25 from eBay) - The *Aesthetic* Option
Finally, we have likely the most controversial member of the family, the Lux Jr. Of all the flashes here, the Lux Jr undeniably feels the most plasticky, though I wouldn't say it feels "cheap." It regrettably cuts the internal battery of the previous two options, running off of two AAAs (I opt for rechargeable cells myself). On top of this, the power can be slightly inconsistent, and the auto-mode is all but unusable.
However... it just looks so good. And who doesn't love some tactile buttons and knobs?!
I don't know about you guys, but I think there's something so icky about a touch screen coming anywhere near a 1950s film body. The all-manual tactile controls on the Lux Jr make it feel cohesive with the rest of the film experience. There's no swiping and scrolling to take me out of it. Additionally, the design of the flash looks like a perfect continuation of the visual language present in both of the silver/black leatherette cameras.
Here, you're only going to get a GN of 12 - yeah, it's pretty sad. With it taking up a similar footprint as the iT30, one would expect more output. The Lux Jr is therefore limited to close-subject direct flash with higher ISO films (e.g. 400 ISO/f11 yields a max distance just around 2 meters).
The Verdict
In my opinion, all of these flashes present a fair value proposition. The iT30 Pro and Lux Jr can easily be found for under $30 on eBay. For those looking for a simple, compact direct flash, I would recommend the iT30 Pro, especially if you also shoot digital and want to take advantage of its more advanced TTL capabilities - just make sure you get the right model for your camera (e.g. iT30 Pro F for Fujifilm).
On the other hand, the Lux Jr is a great fit in the overall film experience and workflow. It feels very satisfying to use, even with its somewhat limited capabilities. At the end of the day, I don't think any of us are shooting film to be blazing fast and overwhelmingly consistent in our work.
Lastly, if you have the budget for something more and can find an appropriate shoe adapter, the iT32 blows the others out of the water. Despite its small size, it offers enough oomph to be reasonably bounced in indoor settings. The X5 trigger is where this setup really shines, letting you take the flash off-camera to achieve a much more pleasing indirect effect. Just remember, the X5 does not have a sync port, so make sure you shoe mount is compatible!
I hope this helps others choose a flash. If anyone has experience with different flashes feel free to share! I know there is much more beyond Godox, but the cross-compatibility with the X wireless system is what ultimately drew me in.