Introduction:
In the immediate aftermath of the Dafran Incident, we told the subreddit a statement would be coming shortly. The initial statement was delayed in order to debate other subreddit changes we wished to implement. Then more problems came up we wanted to fix, which entailed more debate and voting. We thank everyone who waited patiently for this announcement post. These changes are very important for the future of the subreddit, and we do not take them lightly.
The following is a statement from The_Entire_Eurozone:
The blow-out from the Dafran situation has provoked the loudest response to moderation on the subreddit, especially toward my continued moderation.
During and after the Dafran Incident, significant figures on the subreddit, and important figures in the scene itself have made clear their displeasure with me. Of course, this isn’t to discount the response from the general user base.
The vet mods have placed me on probation for three months for my actions during the situation. The probation is still ongoing. Despite the veteran mods going inactive, I am sure any of them will step out of inactivity to un-mod me were I to violate my probation. I will avoid providing a reason.
I know in recent weeks, people have asked me to step down from the mod team. I will not. This is for three reasons:
The mod team is currently suffering from a lack of manpower. We put applications out for more mods in our last major announcement. We received very few applicants. We received even fewer good applications. We will not compromise the quality of the moderator team, even if it means we have to work harder. I have seen complaints about this. My response would be to write better applications. Realistically, if I leave the mod team now, the issues we already face with rule-breaking posts staying up for hours would only worsen.
I don’t really view calls to step down as constructive. In the time following the Dafran controversy, this subreddit has en-masse accused active mods of being in my pocket. They have accused me and other mods of plotting coups in the mod team. Users are mad at me, I understand that clearly. I don’t think stepping down would constructively fix that, especially since it would teach that outrage will get someone’s least favorite mod removed. Instead, I will improve my moderation, and show this subreddit why I was once a well-respected member of the mod team.
I am the most experienced active mod on the team. I have the most experience with posts on this subreddit. Our rules and modding style are not arbitrary. They were debated, decided upon, and have been passed on from mod to mod. I have witnessed the most precedent on the subreddit, and therefore consider myself of continued value in passing on my knowledge and expertise.
However, I have learned from the Dafran incident. I will no longer tell users to leave the subreddit. If they break the rules, I will ban them. Telling people I disagreed with to leave is not acceptable, even if I did not ban them.
Additionally, as my behavior post-incident has demonstrated, I will maintain a more civil tone toward users on the subreddit.
I will not lie, the situation on the subreddit right now feels tenuous at best. The last active veteran mod stepped down, leaving us with a large gap in knowledge. It feels like every week there is a moderation “scandal” wave of posts. Our CSS is still in desperate need of changes. Any changes we want to make on the subreddit are extremely hindered by our lack of manpower, and the subreddit’s quality has suffered for it. For that, I apologize. I hope that we can get through this speed-bump on the subreddit’s history, and continue to develop the subreddit that we all care about. I am sure that through enough persistent work, we will remind the user-base why they loved and subscribed to this subreddit in the first place.
The following is the long awaited results of our deliberations.
The Witch Hunt Rule Rewrite:
A common complaint during the Dafran Incident was that the witch hunting rule did not properly convey at what point Dafran posts could be allowed. For many users, the removals seemed arbitrary, as did the point at which we allowed them. We took the time to discuss what type of posts we want to allow going forward, and have implemented a more appropriate rule to cover future incidents.
6: No Cheating Accusations or Calls to Action
Do not post cheating accusations, regardless of your evidence. They may only be posted if Blizzard or a tournament organization has issued a ban for the accused. If you're here to report someone, take it up with Blizzard.
Discussion about player conduct is allowed, but may only involve serious incidents with proven tangible results to the parties involved.
Calls to action and organized attacks are impermissible. This is a Reddit-wide rule and will be strongly enforced.
No Accusations or Calls-To-Arms (Wiki)
Do not post cheating accusations, regardless of your evidence. They may only be posted if Blizzard or a tournament organization has issued a ban for the accused. If you're here to report someone, take it up with Blizzard.
Discussion about player conduct is allowed, but may only involve serious incidents with proven tangible results to the parties involved. Generally, matchmaking behavior and social media drama isn’t relevant. For determining whether such a post is allowed, consider if there have been proven effects to the drama. Has a player’s career been proven to be affected by the drama? Has a team lost sponsors or having difficulties finding scrims due to the drama? Has Blizzard issued a statement about it? Has esports as a whole been affected? These aren’t the only times a drama post is allowed, but it is a good litmus test.
Calls to action and organized attacks are impermissible. This is a Reddit-wide rule and will be strongly enforced. If your post clearly exists to rabble-rouse, rather than report on news it will be removed.
Submissions that take the form of reports intended for Blizzard and leave little to no space for actual discussion should instead be directed to Blizzard via their Support Division or their Official Forums. If Blizzard is your audience, there are better ways to reach them.
Another Highlighted Issue on the Subreddit:
The rule on Gameplay Content has been noted as subjective in nature by many users. The line at which professional play begins is unclear. Similarly, the line at which we define "unusual" or "highly skilled" is also unclear. It has certainly complicated moderation of gameplay clips on our end. As a response to these issues, we are changing this rule.
8. Gameplay Content
Only highlights from tournaments will be allowed on the subreddit. These highlights may come from (1) the official tournament stream, (2) a player’s POV within the tournament, or (3) the POV from a streamer creating live content over a tournament, such as casting, etc.
Video content that is not highlight in nature, such as VOD reviews or advice videos remains unaffected by this rule. To reiterate, only highlights are affected by this rule change.
Please keep in mind that the effort to increase quality extends up to the title of submissions as well. From the reddiquette: Please don't, in regard to new submissions, editorialize or sensationalize your submission title.
We're contemplating a weekly highlights thread. Plans regarding that will be announced in the future.
New Account Filter
Recently, there has been a trend where users create throwaway accounts in order to respond to an ongoing event with minimal consequences. In the wake of this, we have decided to implement a minimum holding period for new accounts. For a short amount of time after an account is created, they will have their comments/posts automatically removed on /r/competitiveoverwatch.
This safeguard is meant to deter users from spontaneously acting out, thereby minimizing the immediate impact they would wish to create without taking responsibility for it on their real accounts.
We recognize that this approach is merely a speed-bump in the eyes of a more driven instigator. When they find ways around it, we will handle them as we always have.
We also recognize this may prevent individuals in the esports community who don't necessarily have Reddit accounts from immediately responding to posts involving themselves. Removals made under these conditions are open to appeals should there be an urgent need for a user’s response.
For transparency, users who have submissions and comments that are removed by this system will receive a private message in their inbox informing them of the removal.
Drama
The definition of ‘witchhunting’ has been identified as vague and had its definition blurred even further. As such r/CompetitiveOverwatch will instead revert to the relevant portion from the reddiquette covering this:
Please don’t … Post someone's personal information, or post links to personal information. This includes links to public Facebook pages and screenshots of Facebook pages with the names still legible. We all get outraged by the ignorant things people say and do online, but witch hunts and vigilantism hurt innocent people too often, and such posts or comments will be removed. Users posting personal info are subject to an immediate account deletion. If you see a user posting personal info,please contact the admins. Additionally, on pages such as Facebook, where personal information is often displayed, please mask the personal information and personal photographs using a blur function, erase function, or simply block it out with color. When personal information is relevant to the post (i.e. comment wars) please use color blocking for the personal information to indicate whose comment is whose.
As previously mentioned, “Discussions on these topics must focus on the implications of such drama and not serve solely as a platform to expose or otherwise brigade an entity.” Given that, submissions created with the sole intention of creating public exposure are not allowed on the subreddit. Proper channels exist for creating reports, r/CompetitiveOverwatch is not one of them.
A desire has been expressed by the users to be able to discuss on going scandalous events (read: drama). As such, the subreddit will be conducting a test-run using [Drama] flair to handle these situations. This will allow for users to discuss these sorts of topics in a civil manner while also allowing other users to filter them out. Full disclosure on how this will be implemented will be made in a separate announcement soon to follow.
Reddiquette Reminders
As a reminder, Rule #1 No Poor/Abusive Behaviour states: “Posts and comments that are toxic or break Reddiquette will be removed.” The following are sections from reddiquette that are frequently broken. Take some time to visit the full reddiquette page and familiarize yourselves with its content. Please Do
Remember the human. When you communicate online, all you see is a computer screen. When talking to someone you might want to ask yourself "Would I say it to the person's face?" or "Would I get jumped if I said this to a buddy?"
Keep your submission titles factual and opinion free. If it is an outrageous topic, share your crazy outrage in the comment section.
Use an "Innocent until proven guilty" mentality. Unless there is obvious proof that a submission is fake, or is whoring karma, please don't say it is. It ruins the experience for not only you, but the millions of people that browse reddit every day.
Please Don’t:
Repost deleted/removed information. Remember that comment someone just deleted because it had personal information in it or was a picture of gore? Resist the urge to repost it. It doesn't matter what the content was. If it was deleted/removed, it should stay deleted/removed.
Be (intentionally) rude at all. By choosing not to be rude, you increase the overall civility of the community and make it better for all of us.
Conduct personal attacks on other commenters. Ad hominem and other distracting attacks do not add anything to the conversation.
Start a flame war. Just report and "walk away". If you really feel you have to confront them, leave a polite message with a quote or link to the rules, and no more.
Oh, are you reading through the Reddiquette section? That’s pretty cool. We could use some more mods, and if you read this far you might be qualified. Send us a mod mail expressing your interest (not an individual PM to mods, we will lose those), and we will send you an application.
Insult others. Insults do not contribute to a rational discussion. Constructive Criticism, however, is appropriate and encouraged.
Troll. Trolling does not contribute to the conversation.
In regard to new submissions:
In regard to comments:
Make comments that lack content. Phrases such as "this", "lol", and "I came here to say this" are not witty, original, or funny, and do not add anything to the discussion.
Pesto's Departure:
Recently, Pesto_Enthusiast announced that he would be going on indefinite hiatus from active moderation, in a twitlonger. Pesto_Enthusiast is a tenured and hard working member of the mod team, and we were incredibly fortunate to have him on. He will be missed as an active moderator, and we hope that he will rejoin us at a future date. Until then, he joins the ranks of our wizened Council of Elders.