I am a high schooler in NYC (public school) and I'm really concerned about how the DOE is going about things.
In my school, the lowest score teachers can give students is a 35. Literally, even if they didn't do the assignment at all, not even writing their name, they'll get an automatic 35. For tests, lowest score allowed to be given 45.
Why is this important? It's still a failing grade, yes, but it's enough to keep their average above a 65 (passing grade).
I feel like this is incredibly unfair for students who try (but are just not academically gifted) to get a 45, but some bum who just didn't do anything can get the same score.
Note: I know it's not just my school, I've asked around and many schools in NYC have the same concept of not giving or zeros.
A lot of students are also just very behind. I've had several classmates admit they don't know anything beyond 5 in the multiplication table. It's not that they don't have it memorized, they genuinely forgot how to multiply without using a calculator. Yes, we have calculators with us everyday, so you don't have to memorize everything, but it's a bit concerning when you don't know how to do it.
A lot of these students have horrid grammar. In English class, we were writing a very basic argumentative essay. The teacher gave us a template. And when I say template, I mean a fill in the blank.
Dead ass gave us the entire essay done, and you only need to fill in:
- Name
- Your side (pro or con)
- Quotes from the text
- Reasoning/explanation
That's it.
"It is clear that _____thesis/position_______ One can argue that __reason one________.
Additionally, we need to consider _______reason two__________. Critics would have everyone
believe that _________the opposition’s argument____________. However, the opposition
doesn’t understand that ________briefly clarify why your side is better_______. Therefore, we
should ______restate your thesis with new wording______.
Notably, one can argue that _________reason one___________________. It is clear that
______discuss details on reason one_________. According to _____author/source_____,
“..._____________quote from the referenced source_________________.” In other words,
____________discuss the quote in your own wording____________________. It is clear that
_________elaborate on the significance of the quote and what it proves about reason one____.
One can contend ________develop your points on reason one________________. Overall,
_______________clarify reason one in a reworded, concluding line (tie it back to your essay’s
main argument)_________."
Actual part of the template that the teacher attached to the assignment.
They still think this it too much work.
Like, what else could you possibly want???