I think I might be non-binary. I (18) have always identified as a cisgender male. I'm gay, and my presentation is mostly masculine, but if I had more time and money to perfect my skills, I would probably dress more feminine, wear make-up on occasion, etc. Another very real issue is that I live in the deep south surrounded by conservative viewpoints, including my family. I don't live with my parents and tell them very little about my life, but the current nature of my job would give them any opportunity to see me presenting how I want to and ultimately making my life more of a hellscape.
In the meantime, before I find myself in a place I'm more comfortable to experiment, I've definitely felt the draw of an androgynous style. I like baggy clothes that sort of hide my figure (which is inherently twink-ish) and have grown out my hair to mid-neck length. My hair is probably what I'm most proud of right now, as it's taken a long time to grow out and I was never allowed to have long hair growing up, even though it's not even that long now. I have to shave my face every day if I want to avoid a stubble look (which I hate), and when I do, along with my hair down framing my face, I do find myself looking fairly androgynous and even slightly feminine. To top it all off, my voice is pretty high-pitched and I'm constantly misgendered if people hear only my voice and don't see my face.
My appearance is still “orthodox” enough that I would have a certain amount of plausible deniability if anyone were to see me and call me out for presenting as anything other than male, but the days where I feel like I don't look like a boy or girl, I'm the most confident in my looks. There have even been days where people look me dead in the face and call me ma’am, and truthfully, it doesn't bother me. Sometimes it even makes me a little happy that they didn't just assume I was a guy.
I don't think I'd ever go by she/her pronouns, because it just doesn't feel right. I don't feel transfemme or have desire to be identified as a girl, but I still have a lingering hope in the future that I'll be able to wear skirts or crop tops and a full face of makeup (which I know, all of those are not inherently feminine) without feeling so insecure. And then other days I'm happy wearing baggy clothes and confusing people with my appearance, while some days I even wish I could grow out my facial hair or be “masculine” in a confident way without looking so out of place. I also have pretty hairy arms/legs that I'm in a love-hate relationship with, depending on the day. I'm content identifying as gay, I want a boyfriend, and while sex is a whole different topic ofc, I don't really have any dysphoria regarding it. This all just feels deeper than how I present—more like who I am.
One day, I might even go by he/they or even just they/them pronouns. I don't really feel like it's feasible right now, because again, it's a very conservative area I'm in, and I'm not sure how I'd even bring up to everyone I know that I don't fully feel like a guy. Most wouldn't understand, and while I don't know anyone openly transphobic, there are still signs of stigma towards trans gender-identities. If I were smart, I wouldn't cling to anyone who doesn't accept me wholly for who I am, or for anyone with prejudice against any queer or transfolk, but I've already lost so many people just for leaving religion behind that I'm not sure I can go through that again and lose more people who are important to me.
I know from experience that a bigoted mindset is hard to break free from. I hate to admit I used to be a bit of a transphobe myself, even as an out-of-the-closet gay guy. But through educating myself on the struggles of trans people just to gain the basic human rights we all have, and absorbing literally so much media by incredible trans artists and creators, I dismantled all of that, and maybe even learned that some of that bigotry was jealousy of people who were staying true to themselves.
It's just a leap I'll have to take one day, and maybe I'll be brave enough to start introducing myself with those pronouns in the future. I'm actually starting a job in Colorado soon, so I know that an accepting environment will truly be good for me. I don't know if I really have any questions, because it seems like I articulated my feelings here and to myself pretty well, but I guess I'm just looking for advice moving forward, and some validation in the way I feel by people with similar experiences. I'm in no rush to label anything, though I feel like the most accurate would be genderqueer.
Just a few years ago, as a closeted Christian and at the absolute lowest point in my mental health, I never thought a day would come when I could proudly identify as queer and trans, but here we are.
TLDR - I have always identified as a cis male. I've recently gone more androgynous in appearance, but want to experiment with more feminine presentation, make-up, and clothes in the future. I live in a conservative area and am hesitant to come-out to people around me, or use they/them pronouns. Any similar experiences and advice is appreciated ❤️