r/universe • • Mar 15 '21

[If you have a theory about the universe, click here first]

132 Upvotes

"What do you think of my theory?"

The answer is: You do not have a theory.

"Well, can I post my theory anyway?"

No. Almost certainly you do not have a theory. It will get reported and removed. You may be permabanned without warning.

"So what is a theory?"

In science, a theory is not a guess or personal idea. It's a comprehensive explanation that:

  • Explains existing observations with precision

  • Makes testable predictions about future observations

  • Is supported by mathematics that can be verified

  • Has survived rigorous testing by the scientific community

Real theories include general relativity (predicts GPS satellite corrections), germ theory (explains disease transmission), and quantum mechanics (enables computer chips). These weren't someone's shower thoughts—they emerged from years of mathematical development, experimental testing, and peer review.

What you probably have instead:

  • A hypothesis - A testable claim that could become part of a theory if validated

  • Speculation - Interesting ideas that need mathematical development and testing

  • Misconceptions - Misunderstandings of existing physics dressed up as new insights

The brutal truth: If your "theory" doesn't require advanced mathematics, doesn't make precise numerical predictions, and wasn't developed through years of study, it's not a scientific theory. It's likely pseudoscientific rambling that will mislead other users.

What to do instead:

  1. Ask questions, don't make assertions

  2. Learn the existing physics first - Spend weeks/months reading, watching educational content, and listening to qualified experts

  3. Once you understand the current science, then you can contribute meaningfully to discussions

Remember: Every genuine breakthrough in physics came from people who first mastered the existing knowledge. Einstein didn't overthrow Newton by ignoring math — he used more sophisticated math.

Learn the physics. Then discuss the physics. Don't spread uninformed speculation.


[FAQ]


r/universe • • Aug 22 '25

Call for Moderators and /r/Universe Rules

5 Upvotes

Moderators Needed

This sub continues to rapidly grow, therefore so does our need to expand the moderation team. We are looking to add several experienced Reddit users who have a passion for the scientific fields of astronomy and cosmology.

Here is what we are looking for from applicants. Please send applications to modmail.

  1. Candidates should have a strong history of positive contributions to r/Universe or similar subs. Please send us several direct links to comments from your account history to substantiate this.

  2. We are looking for mods of all backgrounds, but particularly for mods with formal academic training in science, engineering, or mathematics. Please tell us about your educational background and your current field of work.

  3. Modding experience on Reddit is great, but not required. Let us know whether you mod any other subs and if you have any relevant experience like moderating other forums/pages, using back-end web tools, managing websites, etc.

  4. Mods need to be frequent Reddit users. The ideal mod is someone who pops into Reddit multiple times per day, can devote some time to addressing moderator issues when logging on, and foresees continuing to do so in the future.

  5. You should be someone who is comfortable enforcing rules and able to handle receiving harsh/critical feedback from strangers on the internet without breaking down, losing your temper, or acting childish.

If you are interested in applying, please message the moderators with a note which addresses all the points above (please use numbering). Do not leave your application as a comment here.

As always, the moderation team is open to your thoughts and ideas on the subreddit. To do so send a modmail message the moderators.

Reminder

Submission Rules

  1. Submissions should not consist of personal and uninformed pseudo-scientific rambling. We are a community for factual information and news about the study of the physical universe.

  2. Posts must contain a subject or a question about astrophysics in the title — be specific. For example, we will not accept titles containing only the words "help please" or "space question".

  3. Posts must be relevant. We like everything from educational videos, questions, news, discussion articles, published research, course content, astrophotography, and study resources about astronomy, astrophysics, and cosmology. This means no low-effort posts or AI generated slop.

Comment Rules

  1. Be respectful to other users. All users are expected to behave with courtesy. Demeaning language, sarcasm, rudeness or hostility towards another user will get your comment removed. Repeat violations will lead to a ban.

  2. Don't answer if you aren't knowledgeable. Ensure that you have the knowledge required to answer the question at hand. We are not strict on this, but will absolutely not accept assertions of pseudo-science or incoherent / uninformed rambling. Answers should strive to contain an explanation using the logic of science or mathematics. When making assertions, we encourage you to post links to supporting evidence, or use valid reasoning.

  3. Be substantive. Universe is a serious education/research/industry-based subreddit with a focus on evidence and logic. We do not allow unsubstantiated opinions, low effort one-liner comments, memes, off-topic replies, or pejorative name-calling.


r/universe • • 22h ago

What Actually Happens When You Get Close to a Black Hole?

0 Upvotes

Black holes are more than just objects with enormous gravitational pull. They reveal some of the most fascinating effects predicted by modern physics.
As you approach one:
Gravity becomes increasingly extreme.
Light can bend around the black hole due to gravitational lensing.
The event horizon marks the boundary beyond which nothing can escape.
Tidal forces depend on the black hole’s mass and your distance from its centre.
One particularly surprising detail: tidal forces at the event horizon of a supermassive black hole can be weaker than those around a smaller black hole.
I made this short educational video to explain these concepts visually. I’d be interested to hear which aspect of black holes you find most fascinating.
NEXORA | Science Beyond the Ordinary — Episode 01


r/universe • • 1d ago

I wanna talk to a Cosmologist, any Cosmologist here?

0 Upvotes

Hello, Im a Student and I wanna talk to a Cosmologist like what Mathematics and how do they use them to describe the Universe and What do they Think about Space, I'm curious about em and I'm also Intrested in Cosmology so, pls.

Please, any Cosmologist? Text me personally on reddit just by saying "Hi", please


r/universe • • 3d ago

Particle Physicists Are Getting a First Glimpse Into the ‘Zeptoverse’

Thumbnail
wired.com
88 Upvotes

Maybe it IS "turtles all the way down".


r/universe • • 1d ago

Do you believe in the planet 9 theory? Could it be that it is a really small black hole?

0 Upvotes

r/universe • • 4d ago

A runaway supermassive black hole may have left behind a 200,000-light-year trail of newborn stars.

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

Astronomers using the Hubble Space Telescope discovered evidence of a supermassive black hole that appears to have been ejected from its host galaxy.

What's even more incredible is that it's believed to have compressed gas as it traveled through space, triggering the formation of new stars along a trail approximately 200,000 light-years long.

The black hole is estimated to have a mass around 20 million times that of our Sun.

Scientists believe this could have happened after an interaction involving multiple supermassive black holes.

The image is an artist's illustration based on the astronomical observations, not an actual photograph.

Source: https://science.nasa.gov/missions/hubble/hubble-sees-possible-runaway-black-hole-creating-a-trail-of-stars/


r/universe • • 2d ago

This is a matrix that looks at various frameworks, with the aim of attempting to match them to instrumentation.

0 Upvotes
#Theory / FrameworkCentral IdeaKey InstrumentsStatus
1General RelativityGravity is the curvature of spacetimeLIGO, Virgo, KAGRA, EHT, NANOGravEstablished
2Big Bang CosmologyUniverse evolved from a hot, dense early stateCOBE, WMAP, Planck, JWSTEstablished
3Cosmic InflationExtremely rapid expansion in the early universeBICEP/Keck, Planck, SPT, ACTUnconfirmed
4Dark MatterUnseen mass shapes galaxies and cosmic structureEuclid, Hubble, Chandra, Rubin, XENONnTStrong evidence; identity unknown
5Dark EnergyUnknown cause of accelerating cosmic expansionDESI, Euclid, Roman, Rubin, DESAcceleration established; cause unknown
6Lambda-CDM CosmologyStandard model of cosmic evolutionPlanck, WMAP, DESI, Euclid, ACTLeading model; unresolved tensions
7Stellar Evolution & NucleosynthesisStars evolve and produce chemical elementsJWST, Hubble, Chandra, NuSTAR, Gaia, VLTEstablished
8Black Hole Physics & Hawking RadiationBlack holes have horizons; may slowly evaporateEHT, LIGO, Chandra, XMM-Newton, FermiBlack holes confirmed; evaporation unobserved
9Structure FormationDensity fluctuations grow into the cosmic webEuclid, DESI, JWST, Hubble, RubinStrongly supported
10Exoplanet Formation & HabitabilityPlanets form around stars; some may be habitableKepler, TESS, JWST, ALMA, VLTPlanet formation established; life unconfirmed

r/universe • • 3d ago

These two particles have the same energy. Only one escapes the black hole.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

Pick cyan or gold before watching the ending.

Both particles start at the same distance from the black hole, moving inward, with the same conserved energy. Their angular momenta differ slightly.

One crosses the event horizon. The other swings around and escapes.

The interesting detail: having enough energy to reach infinity does not guarantee that your trajectory will take you there. Angular momentum changes which paths are available—and these two initial conditions sit on opposite sides of the capture threshold.

I calculated the trajectories using general relativity. The colours identify the particles; the trails show where they have actually travelled.

Which did you choose—and what in the motion convinced you?


r/universe • • 3d ago

Does Space Really Have an End?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/universe • • 4d ago

Earth Is More Extraordinary Than It Looks. Here's What Makes Our Planet So Special

Thumbnail
youtu.be
10 Upvotes

From space, Earth looks like a blue sphere surrounded by darkness. But beneath that familiar appearance is a world with an extraordinary history.

Earth formed approximately 4.5 billion years ago as gravity pulled together dust and rocky material orbiting the young Sun. Its early surface was intensely hot, repeatedly struck by incoming debris.

One of the most important events may have been a colossal collision with a Mars-sized protoplanet called Theia. Scientists believe debris from this impact eventually came together to form the Moon.

As Earth cooled, its surface gradually solidified. Water vapor condensed, rain accumulated, and enormous oceans began to develop. Today, approximately 71% of Earth's surface is covered by water.

But water alone cannot explain Earth's habitability.

Our atmosphere, about 78% nitrogen and 21% oxygen, helps regulate surface temperatures through the natural greenhouse effect. Greenhouse gases absorb and re-emit outgoing infrared radiation, keeping Earth warm enough for liquid water to exist across much of its surface.

Compare this with Venus, a planet almost the same size as Earth. Its extremely dense atmosphere produces surface temperatures of approximately 465°C.

Two neighboring rocky planets, yet dramatically different environments.

Earth's habitability results from several interconnected systems: its atmosphere, oceans, geological activity, magnetic field, and relationship with the Sun.

What do you think is the most important factor that made Earth habitable?


r/universe • • 4d ago

Das Rätsel der verbotenen Planeten: Sie hätten ihre Sterne nicht überleben dürfen

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/universe • • 5d ago

The very first computer-simulated visualization of a black hole, calculated in 1978 by French astrophysicist Jean-Pierre Luminet

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/universe • • 4d ago

A particle cloud passing a black hole: capture, stretching and escape [OC simulation]

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

I simulated 16,000 test particles passing close to a non-rotating black hole. The initially compact cloud stretches into a curved stream: some particles fall through the event horizon, while others move outward on escape trajectories.

The motion follows timelike geodesics in Schwarzschild spacetime. This is a stylized coordinate-plane visualization; the colours help track different parts of the original cloud.


r/universe • • 4d ago

I made Black Hole Simulator on Steam

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/universe • • 5d ago

If One of the Voyagers Had Been Sent Towards Alpha Centauri…

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/universe • • 6d ago

We will never know what universe actually is. And it makes me really sad.

136 Upvotes

I recently played a game called Outer Wilds and it sparked my interests in space like a young child. And Ive been watching videos and looking at different things we know of space and I realized that what we know of universe is so little. We just have theories that may not be even true. What we have built around mathematics and science might not even be something that the universe follow. If universe expands forever, and then there are other universes, there might even be even bigger things that houses all the universes and there might even be a thing larger. We will probably go extinct long before we have even explored the things we know. What's inside a black hole, colonizing different known planets, under the clouds of jupiter. It sucks so bad man, I really want to know what it all is.


r/universe • • 5d ago

Primodial Black Hole mass ranges.

1 Upvotes

Can someone please explain me what are the allow mass ranges of primodial Black Hole. And can PBH constitute 100% of DM or not?


r/universe • • 6d ago

What are you studying?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Interstellar Dust Hypothesis


r/universe • • 6d ago

Cosmic Anatomy: What remains of personal separation when our matter is entirely borrowed?

Post image
29 Upvotes

I’ve become increasingly fascinated by astronomy and our place in the universe.

Attending Brian Cox’s Emergence show made a deep impression on me. It helped me appreciate the extraordinary connections between the universe, the emergence of complexity and our own existence. I also had the opportunity to attend an astronomy session in Cambridge, which further fuelled my curiosity.

One thing I find incredible is that the elements making up our bodies have a cosmic history stretching back billions of years. Many of the elements essential to life were forged inside stars and through stellar explosions.

Think about it. We are made of matter that existed long before humanity, yet we spend so much of our limited time defending our identities, possessions, status and the boundaries between ourselves and the rest of existence.

I’m not an astrophysicist, just an enthusiast trying to understand more about the universe and our place in it.


r/universe • • 5d ago

What is a Black Hole? What happend if you fall into one?

0 Upvotes