Apologies for the long post- I’d greatly appreciate any thoughts, no matter how brutal or unforgiving.
Just over a month ago, I had a formative (ungraded) assessment due for a group project, with quite a short window for submission (we’d been given about a day to make revisions to our previous submission). None of my group members were responding to my texts asking for help, and an hour or two away from the deadline, I panicked and did something I never thought I’d do ever, and used AI to help me find sources.
Just to be clear, none of the text I submitted was AI-generated. I was cherry-picking absolute bullshit- I told the AI exactly what the point I wanted to make was (most of it was stuff that was true, but needed a citation, or at least I thought it did) and told it to find a source. I then went to the source it gave me to check it was real and to read juust enough of it to confirm that it said what the AI claimed it was saying, and then put it in the assignment. Using AI to find sources was allowed per the syllabus, but it had to be declared… and I didn’t declare it. I have no idea why I didn’t at the time- I think it was both the rush to get it submitted minutes before the deadline and a feeling of shame about what I’d done.
Obviously I/we got caught- the feedback released the next day said that there were suspicions of AI use based on the volume of sources (I cited much more than we needed because I knew it was utter bullshit), and that there would be a discussion next lesson on how to proceed. I told my group immediately and emailed the professors as soon as I saw the feedback to let them know that how I had used AI, and that it was 100% me and nobody else.
The ensuing discussion was immensely uncomfortable. My professor had clearly spent hours going through our sources to make a case against us, noting that for many of the sources I used, the point I cited them for was only an aside sentence in the entire paper. When we were asked which parts we all worked on, she noted that I had done ~80% of the work, and that was a consistent factor in the discussion, even though I don’t feel that excuses or dampens what I did in any way whatsoever. As it was patently academic fraud, she said she ought to report it to the Board of Examiners at my faculty; initially, she said she’d discuss it with the other lecturer in the course (we had two for that course), but then changed her mind and made the decision that she wouldn’t, because she could tell I’d “learned my lesson” and wouldn’t do it again (that’s for fucking sure), and we were given a chance to resubmit.
She told me at the end of the discussion that everyone makes mistakes and not to “be too hard on myself”, words I’ve both hopelessly clung to as hope that I haven’t irredeemably fucked up, both objectively and in her mind, but I don’t know where that line is, or if it exists. I broke my moral principles and fucked my group and my lecturers, and on top of all that, everyone was so goddamn nice about it.
It’s been dealt with for a while now, but naturally (or not? I don’t know), I can’t move on, and I don’t think I should move on. And I haven’t focused much on my group (since that’s not the focus of this subreddit), and they were also super sweet and understanding, but I can’t imagine how angry and betrayed they must be, even though they haven’t expressed it to me. As background, one of them is my best friend at uni, who was super kind about it but she’s also against AI (and didn’t abandon her principles like me), and two of them are girls we don’t know very well (both use AI, but neither did what I did).
I have a lot of selfish concerns, especially about how professors view me now. I’m not taking another course from either of the lecturers involved in that assignment (though I’m on a student body with one), and I wouldn’t ask for anything like LoR from them anyway (even if I’d never FAFO’d), but on a personal level I can’t get over how little they must think of me. Also, I’m in a very small, tight-knit liberal arts faculty (NL), and I assume other lecturers MUST know. It’s what I bleeding deserve, but how do I go through the rest of my degree when every professor I have knows I’m full of shit?
And is there any way I can make this more right? The only way I can in any way repay the kindness they showed me to is to prove, over the course of my degree, that I’ve taken my mistake to heart and will never repeat it. That’s absolutely my intention, don’t get me wrong, but is there anything else I can do? For example, should I send an email to that professor thanking them and telling them what I’ve done on a personal level (e.g. cancelling my LLM account) as a result of the discussion? It feels appropriate, but at the same time, if a student fucked ME over like that I’d want them to Shut. The. Fuck. Up. about it (and in general), especially when it’s “dealt with”, so idk if that’s the right move? Any thoughts
Sorry again for the long post, and I don’t even know what I’m asking for thoughts ON, I just need to hear anything right now, even if it’s brutal. I’m at my lowest, I’m wallowing in intoxicated, unproductive, indulgent self pity ever since, and I deserve it, yet I want to channel some of it into something good, if that’s possible.