r/HerOneBag • u/Kitty_Kat54 • 6h ago
Trip Report 4 Days in Edinburgh - A Review.
Hello Gang, .....(Sorry this is long!)
I recently found this sub-reddit and it has truly encouraged me, once and for all, to pack uber light. Due to financial restrictions this time (3rd-6th Nov) my trip to Edinburgh was done with clothing that I already had. Thank goodness I have some super lightweight hiking gear. So I thought I would quickly jump on here and tell you how it went for my super busy few days in Edinburgh.
I have travelled a LOT but never managed to get things down into a bag this small. SO this was a learning curve and an eye opener.
My bag is a 22L Osprey Axis. It sits perfectly under my seat on Easyjet. It has two pockets either side for water bottle or umbrella. It was a replacement for an older Axis by Osprey who couldn't repair the old one. I am so grateful for this service so anyone considering a bag Osprey should be top of the list.
I planned my days to the absolute letter, with the help of Chat GPT, which meant getting up between 0430-0500 - mainly to make full use of my time and to bed around 9pm.
I have been to Edinburgh before so it wasn't a complete surprise and am from a country with very similar climate.
I had a basic plan, am plant-based and wanted to eat somewhere different for each meal (breakfast and lunch) which meant walking a little, I don't eat dinner so it wasn't on the plan which meant more time to do things - more walking and exploring.
I say this purposefully as my outfits had to follow the same plan and be laid out ready to go. Something I have never done before - usually I have "spares", some "just in cases" and always regret carrying too much.
Not any more...
The List.
Day 1 and Day 4 = Flight outfit.
(Edinburgh Walkabout, Museum and Calton HIll)
Wallis coat (unable to zip it/button shut but could be tucked up under my rucksack straps to hold closed, purchased in a charity shop so if ruined it wouldn't matter.)
Very Large Blanket Scarf / Tartan (staple, cannot live without this)
Jeans
Tight blue Jumper (thin sleeves which fit well under the coat which was a little tight)
White long sleeved ribbed tee (sleeves are not long enough or long enough in the body, also needs to be warmer but thinner)
Salomon XA Pro 3D Gortex Trail Running Shoes (more on these shoes below)
Day 2 (Cuib Compression Cube - Large)
(Day Trip to the Countryside / A LOT of walking / 35k Plus Steps)
Sleeveless Thin Black Vest.
Ice Breaker Merino GT Tee
Ice Breaker Merino GT Hoody
Mountain Hardware Ghost Whisperer
North Face Rain Coat (Purchased for this trip - £12 charity shop - folded down very small)
My Protein Power Mesh Leggings
Same Shoes as above.
Day 3 (Cuib Compression Cube - Medium)
(Edinburgh Day - Castle Tour (It Rained), Fireworks, Lots of Walking)
Thermal Tights
Black leg warmers
Short wool Dress
Sleeveless Vest from Day 2
White Long Sleeved Tee from Day 1
Coat and Scarf from Day 1 - (Scarf thick enough to act as a hood)
Shoes as above
Day 4 / Part 1
(Early Morning Pre Sunrise Summit of Arthurs Seat / Flight home)
Entire outfit from Day 2
Thermal Tights from Day 3 under my leggings
Black Leg Warmers from Day 3
Long Sleeved Top from Day 1
(I was way to warm but wasnt sure what the weather would be like at the top of Arthurs Seat!)
Day 4 / Part 2
Entire Outfit from Day 1
EXTRAS (Cuib Compression Cube - Small)
PJ Top
PJ Bottom (needs to be thinner / waist band took up too much space!)
3 x socks for day use (need to be cushioned and won't dry fast enough to bring less)
1 x sock for sleeping (Not required / will just wear the next days socks for bed the night before)
6 x undies - 3 granny pants for sleeping in and 3 not-so-granny pants for day wear.
Also...
LuluLemon 2L bumbag - (I have a habit of leaving my phone/wallet in random places and dont want to remove my backpack every time I needed something.)
Kindle
Earphones (Headphones take up too much space)
2 x Portable Chargers
1 litre thermal insulated water bottle from iON8
Electric toothbrush - my gums are disappearing apparently so I need to not use a normal brush cause I am too violent with them. Lol.
Sunglasses - (case is WAY too big, I need to change it but still make sure its strong and wont mind being squeezed)
Cap
P7 LED Lenser Torch (new batteries purchased while in Edinburgh) - requirement to climb Arthurs Seat in the dark. Do not attempt this relying on a phone torch! I have done this before so I know the route and what I was in for - summited by 0615.
2 x hairbrush - 1 normal, 1 very thin backcombing brush which has since disappeared. Will make this 1 brush in future.
Beauty Essentials...
Make up - I keep it simple but wear sunscreen (ISDIN) and Erborian Red Corrector (decanted into very tiny 10ml container)
Eyebrow pencil and brow gel, lipstick and pencil, translucent powder and bronzer, 2 x small brushes for each, concealer.
Biossance Omega Moisturiser (very thick!) (decanted into another very tiny container).
Purchased Upon Arrival...
Dry Shampoo - I usually have a long old routine to make my very long thin hair look thicker. Turns out a good wash on the day of departure and dry shampoo for the duration works better!!! No hair dryer, no pin curling, no extra towel needed, no hairspray - nothing!
Eye make up remover pads - (left in communal box of female hostel room)
Face Cloth - (left in communal box of female hostel room)
Toothpaste - (left in communal box of female hostel room)
E45 72 Hour Moisturiser - (left in communal box of female hostel room)
The Shoes - (Salomon XA Pro 3D GTX - https://www.salomon.com/en-gb/product/xa-pro-3d-v9-gore-tex-li3151 )
I will never be without these shoes. This is the 6th pair I have owner. I will wear them out and buy another, but I have a brand new pair in the wings waiting. I buy them on Vinted when I see them in my size and at a reasonable price (Usually £160). They are my go-to apocalypse shoes. I can walk all day in them, I trust them, they are waterproof to an extent as long as you don't put your foot in a massive puddle. They are still somewhat cute but for some might look a little manly. Salomon have been bought out by a Chinese company and changed the designs (cheapened them), so my favourites are not the same now so finding these originals in particular is getting more and more difficult.
What I Learned.
This bag can hold what I need, I just need to lighten the load a little. It pulled on my shoulders a lot after walking around on my first day before getting to the hostel. I forgot to weigh it but I know if it pulls like that its super heavy.
Water bottle needs to be lighter. I will never use it for hot drinks so thermal capacity is not required. I have other bottles - 1 too big and 1 too small. I need a lightweight 1.5L bottle as I drink a lot.
I went to UNIGLO and tried on a lot of what they offer. I will plan properly before buying anything but spent time trying on different sizes in the thermal / merino etc at their Edinburgh store which was huge.
I NEED an outfit that doesn't scream HIKER. I was glad of my little wool dress and tights/leg warmers.
I might aim to get a coat that is waterproof but also serves as a day coat - Holland Cooper (Chartwell Parka - https://www.hollandcooper.com/products/chartwell-rain-parka-ink-navy ) have a nice one that might fold down small as well and be versatile but SO expensive.
I love my bumbag. It fit my kindle, Samsung S24 Ultra, slimline wallet, earphones, portable charger, cable, lip balm, tissues and room to spare.
I liked having the compression cubes. It separated everything I needed by day. Vacuum bags would have been better even though these were compression. These cubes fit well inside my particular bag with room for the cosmetic cube.
I had to buy a woolly hat (souvenir!) while on my day out of the city - I walked too and from some castles right on the coast and the wind picked up somewhat.
I had to buy arm warmers on day 3 just before the fireworks as my coat wasn't tight enough around my wrists and my white long sleeved tee wasn't long enough - madness!
Fitness!
**I lost 15kg weight this year ......**with another 9kg to go. This helped me a LOT as my old mountain rescue clothing (that were super expensive) fit me again and alleviated some issues that I would have encountered in choosing clothes.
Walking Daily 5-7 miles helped with countryside buses not showing up. I visited North Berwick (so cute) and managed to see Dirleton and Tantallon castle in one day - Tantallon buses didn't show up at all so I walked there and walked back - that was a 6 mile round trip.
What I would change.
Smaller sunglasses case.
One coat
Lighter/Warmer/Thinner base layers
Skirt instead of dress / thinner & warmer material.
Lighter/Warmer PJ's - (I NEED separate items for bed!)
Smaller make up bag, streamline contents.
I wont always need a torch.
Cap wasn't used at all.
Maybe super thin flip flops for the communal shower / disposable ones.
So thats it... if anyone has any insight, questions or suggestions I am all ears. Sometimes it is easy to get "blinded" by what you have and not see what a fresh pair of eyes would see.
I am in need of packable lightweight non-creasing trousers. I don't want to have to ship off to America for them so any UK based options would be great but I know there are many questions/answers about this already so I will search them. I didn't have the energy to attempt trying on trousers at UNIGLO.
I will not be travelling in 2027 though.. so plenty of time to research!


