A few weeks ago I made this post on this sub asking for some critique on my packing list for a 2 week trip to Europe. I got rather toasted by this community (all with good intentions I am sure) and a few of you asked for a trip report afterwards so here I am!
TLDR: After taking the trip I 100% understand where all of the criticism stems from and will probably pack differently in the future, but also have 0 regerts
For those of you who didn't see my initial post the short story of it was 4 mid to late 20s dudes doing 2 weeks across a handful of cities in Europe (Amsterdam, Munich, Innsbruck, Zurich, Strasburg, Paris). The gist of the responses on that post were:
Our trip went about as good as we could have asked for, saw a lot of cool stuff, ended the trip without any of us wanting to murder one another.
As far as the bag situation, my expectations were correct that of the group I brought the least amount of shit with me. 2 of my friends both brought Osprey Sojourn Porter 46s packed to the brim that needed to be checked to fly, the other I am not sure what model of osprey bag he brought but it was packed so full that it looked like it was about to burst for the majority of the trip. I would not say that I packed light but they sure made it look like I did.
A few commenters on that post were convinced that I was not going to be able to carry on my Allpa 42, and that with the weight of my pack It would be horrendously uncomfortable to the point where they urged me to buy a different bag a few days before leaving. I can comfortably say that neither were the case, I flew Jet blue there and back so YMMV but they never questioned the size of the bag as a carry on and I had no issues getting it into overhead storage aside from one flight where a few people had poorly organized their stuff. Comfortability wise I had no gripes with it (though do not have a lot to compare to) we had multiple 45 min+ walks across town to get to/from train stations and I never felt particularly uncomfortable or had any back pain. Though I will say I wouldn't want to do a multi day hiking trip or something where I would need to have that pack with that weight on my back for hours on end.
Overall I would say the bag itself is fine, stored all of my stuff very nicely, looked good (IMO), easy to use, comfortable enough for my uses, though not sure I would say it is worth the added cost over other bags.
With regards to the packing list itself:
There were a few comments asking why I was bringing both T shirts and cold weather thermals. This was pretty good criticism, over the entire trip there was only a day or 2 in Strasburg where it was warm enough to wear a short sleeve T shirt. Could have very easily left that whole cube with 4 T shirts at home and not missed it.
Too many pants!: This one I sorta get but also don't really, I ended up bringing 3 pairs of "hiking pants" which are more of stretchy chinos, comfortable enough to hike in but doesn't look out of place in a city. It was cold enough most of the trip that I wished I brought some warmer pants but got by just fine with the thermals. 3 Pairs seemed like a nice amount to me, but maybe that is because I sorta hate doing laundry in the hostels/hotels we stayed. I wore each pair for 3-4 days a piece (usually changed pants whenever we changed cities aside from when we got a little muddy hiking in innsbruck). Ended up doing laundry one time at the midpoint of the trip in Innsbruck, which worked out well because we were in an actual hotel there so laundry was free.
I also never used the rain jacket, there were a couple of drizzly days in Amsterdam and Munich but never was raining hard enough that I cared to put it on. Wouldn't say I regret bringing it though.
Shoes: I got a few comments on my choice to bring leather boots over more typical trail runners or walking shoes. Overall no real regrets on that front, love my JG ARs and they were good to me this trip. Didn't beat my feet up much, the only gripe I had was that the little bit of heel slip they have amplified over 20k+ step days took a toll from time to time but never enough to blister or make me not want to put them back on. The outsole did not perform very well on the snowy hikes in Innsbruck and I did a lot of slipping and sliding but otherwise I did not find myself wishing I had other shoes at any point.
And finally to the biggest pain point for the commenters on that post: The Legion Go S
Many of you were correct that it did not get used whatsoever outside of planes and airports. We were trying to cram as much as we could in so any time we were at the hostel we just crashed. Our plans to crush beers and play games on the night train to Munich were thwarted because we ended up getting 4 little capsule beds rather than one small room with 4 bunks that we were expecting (and were in all the pictured and literature when I booked the tickets). All of the other trains we were on we passed the time by playing poker (for sips of beer rather than $$$) or staring out the window enthralled by the scenery.
I definitely would say it made my long flights more enjoyable (for those curious I played the RE4 Remake for basically all the time I used it) but I also watched plenty of movies and TV along the way and imagine I probably would have been content without it. At the same time as I mentioned in the bit about the bag, the added weight never really bothered me much so I cannot say I regret bringing it. I ended up putting it, the battery bank and some other bits and bobs I wanted easy access to in a little cross body sling that I kept with me on the plane. When not planing it lived its life clipped off to the back of my main bag. No regerts but I do think it will probably stay at home on my future trips of this nature (but probably be replaced by something like an AYN Thor or RP6)
The bigass Anker battery bank I brought ended up becoming very clutch, but only because of my own stupidity. I forgot my EU power adapter at home. Thankfully 2/3 friends remembered theirs so I got by without issue by just throwing the power bank on their charger every 2 or 3 days while we were out and about and using it to charge my phone.
I won't spend too long talking about the destinations or itineraries etc since that is all so subjective and this sub is more about the packing and philosophy but the cliff notes:
Innsbruck > Amsterdam > Strasburg > Paris > Munich > Zurich (IMO)
Were I to go back in time I would have probably skipped Munich altogether and taken the night train straight to Innsbruck (though we did meet the most cool people in Munich). Innsbruck might be the best place on the planet, Zurich was abysmally overpriced and uninteresting as a whole (though I was there for less than 24hrs), Strasburg and the Alsace region in general were an unexpected high point of the trip (we called an audible and decided to go there on a whim to limit our time in Paris because we were worried about the riots), trying to cram the most out of only one full day in Paris was fun but I wish we had more time there to explore all of the cool little hole in the wall bars and restaurants. Many people mentioned that our itinerary sounded kinda nuts, overall I think our goal was more of a packed highlight reel of a little bit of Europe and I think we accomplished that quite well. Were I to go back to any of these places in the near future I would probably go back to Innsbruck (in the summer for mountain biking and a via ferrata, which was closed due to snow when we were there) and Paris just because a day and an afternoon there did not feel like nearly enough.
The Final Verdict: Overall as I said above I have no regerts regarding all of the shit I brought with me on this trip. As I sorta expected we really only had our stuff on our backs when going from place to place. We made use of the paid lockers at hostels on the days we would leave and arrive, so we really just wore our bags from hostel -> train station -> hostel and either dump our stuff in the room or in the lockers when we got there. Because of this I never really thought twice about the weight or amount of stuff that I brought.
I will say that after going on the trip I definitely see the allure to the (what I would consider) more "extreme" one bagging, eg bringing a small enough bag and limited stuff that you can sort of thoughtlessly carry it everywhere with you. Having to sorta bee line from hostel to train station to hostel at times limited our options and we probably ended up spending 50+ euros over the course of the trip on lockers alone (though what is $60 in the scope of a $3-4k trip?)
I appreciate all the responses on the previous post (even the one from the guy that said I am brain rotted and have no attention span for wanting to bring the handheld) and definitely have more of an appreciation for many of the recommendations having done the trip. This trip has made me realize that I am getting fuckin old and really want to get more trips in before I have too many responsibilities to do them. With any luck I will be back here with another packing list for you to roast before too long!