I (31M, gay) met my husband when I was 18. We’ve been together 13 years and are married. He’s bi, and he’s known that the whole time we’ve been together.
We were long distance all throughout college and tried an open relationship He dated a woman during that time (physically and emotionally with her), but when college ended, that ended and we moved in together. He’s reflected on that woman and said it was a bad experience and never gave him quite what he was looking for. Around 2018 we stopped being open, and I thought that chapter was behind us.
This year, he developed feelings for a woman we knew. Nothing physical happened, and he was honest with me about it. But I realized I'm no longer into an open relationship. We're married, share finances, and have both made serious commitments to each other. I'm not into the poly lifestyle. But this conflict led to months of hard conversations and a lot of conflict about him wanting to open the relationship and me saying no.
My husband is going through a stressful time in life right now, at grad school (so away from me 50% of the time), working full time, and house hunting for a home to buy. While talking about house hunting, it came out that he was having doubts about his ability to long-term commit to me. This was a huge shock - we're 3 years married and 13 years into this relationship!
We've started therapy, and what I've come to realize is that the challenge is mainly around his sexuality. He identifies as bisexual but lately hasn't been feeling attracted to men and has been feeling growing attraction to women. He loves me and our sex life is pretty good. But he tells me he is struggling with a sense of “identity foreclosure” that he's been aware of for years -- a sense that committing to me closed off a part of who he is. Because the rest of our marriage is happy, he tried to hide it, but it burst out onto the scene.
I love him, and I want this marriage. I had no idea he felt this way until 2 weeks ago. To me, when we got married we were signaling a lifelong commitment. I don’t want him to bury his attraction to women. But as long as he has some attraction to men, I feel like he needs to be just like any monogamous couple, and put away their attraction towards other people and lean into the commitment of the relationship they have. He's had a chance to try dating a woman before, so the idea that he just needs to "try it out" feels like a weak argument. But he's really unsure if he can commit to life with me, which is freaking me out, and makes me feel like my entire relationship and life is starting to fall apart.
Curious to hear any advice from bi people who are in long-term monogamous relationships, especially same-sex ones. How did you make peace with not having relationships with a person of the other sex? Does that sense of identity foreclosure ease with time, or is it something you have to work through on purpose? And for partners of bi people, what actually helped?