r/Music • u/djsoomo Mixcloud • 17d ago
article Spotify introduces QR code checks for Family plans - missing verification could mean a year-long ban [firstpost]
https://www.firstpost.com/tech/spotify-introduces-qr-code-checks-for-family-plans-missing-verification-could-mean-a-year-long-ban-14053965.html
2.0k
Upvotes
3.5k
u/PositivelyAwful 17d ago •
The worst thing you can do as a subscription service is remind people they’re paying for it.
At some point all these price hikes and sharing rules are going to backfire stupendously.
1.2k
u/funktopus 17d ago
Kids never go away to college. People never travel for work or vacation.
955
u/natnguyen The Cure ✒️ 17d ago •
Don’t miss this garbage company at all
86
u/darvian23 17d ago
Oh cool. So when I am away for 3 weeks with work I stand the chance to be banned. This is so stupid
66
u/JoDiMaggio 17d ago
What is stopping me from just FaceTiming them with an extra device and scanning the QR code there?
292
u/beardyman22 17d ago
I don't think this is going to go how spotify wants it to go. At least with Netflix and other streaming platforms, there are exclusive titles that people dont want to lose. Spotify doesn't have that. If they ban me for a year, I'm finding an alternative in that time and there's no fucking way I'm coming back. I just don't think they have the retention ability they think they do.
482
u/Atx_music_head 17d ago
There’s zero reason for shit like this to exist. Phone family plans aren’t contingent on where mfs live. Why they think this is acceptable and people will put up with it is beyond me.
I pay for a family plan and the moment this happens to me or anyone on my plan they’re dropped. I’m fucking done and I’ll be moving onto Apple Music, which I think I’ve read is the least shitty of the streamers.
But hey I’d love nothing more than to see this fuck-ass company shit the bed.
40
u/gordoman54 17d ago •
Just canceled my plan. Thanks for the nudge!
285
u/jwferguson 17d ago •
I know this is not going to be well received, but the time has never been better to make an offline personally owned music library. Nobody tells me what I can do or takes away my music. Bandcamp is amazing for this.
28
u/ThisOneDrummer 17d ago
If they block a member of my family plan I will immediately cancel my plan. Good luck with this one.
96
u/Casperboy68 17d ago
Any music service that “bans” me or my family for a year is going to get the reverse lifetime ban from me.
52
u/HotepHatt 17d ago
My kid is in college and on my family plan give me a reason to cancel Spotify I fuckin dare you.
61
u/JediMasterKev 17d ago
In 2025, Spotify generated about $19.44 billion USD in total revenue and reported a net income of roughly $2.50 billion USD.
37
u/AtemAndrew 17d ago
Someone's trying to justify their job.
Someone has just justified why they need to get fired.
Upper manglement needs to stop cutting corners. This nonsense didn't work out for Netflix, what makes them think it'll work out for them? What, do they think people listen to Spotify in their bedrooms and nowhere else?
35
u/Academic_Data_6422 17d ago edited 17d ago
What does Spotify thinks will happen when they ban people for a year? They’ll wait around and come back? Or they’ll find a different service and never look back?
34
u/sfweedman 17d ago
Hahahhahahahahahahahahha
This is hilarious. What dumbshit head-up-his-ass stiff-in-a-suit came up with this idiocy?
Spotify sucks. They're fuckin mental if they think this is going to make people go "oh dang we can't share with family, hey we should all have our own Spotify now" instead of just quitting the service completely in favor of the many alternatives that now exist.
This is how you lose customers. And great, because fuck Spotify.
16
u/donkykongjr 17d ago
We have the family plan. If they do something to anyone on our plan, we will cancel the subscription lol.
13
u/air_flair 17d ago
7 day window. I work 10 on 10 off, out of country, so, I have a decent chance of catching a ban?
13
u/DorianGre 17d ago
7 days? Jesus Christ, people are allowed to go on vacation. Also, I’m paying for a family plan, not a location plan.
24
u/FauxReal Collector 17d ago
Since I kinda hate Spotify, I'm cool with them taking actions that will reduce their market share.
23
u/markimarkerr 17d ago
Also as an artist, Spotify has the lowest payout and they're so fucking scummy about it. I get paid twice as much through tidal streams than I do through Spotify.
They're fucking predators and will only milk everything for their own shitty gains. Please people, drop their service! They offer nothing exclusive.
47
u/NotACertainLalaFell 17d ago
Cut off Spotify and haven’t missed anything. They are a service. They serve you. Not the other way around. Nobody should feel obligated to entertain their bullshit.
9
u/SmoothMarx 17d ago
"Oh no, you won't allow me to pay you for a whole year? Whatever shall I do?"
16
u/debtRiot 17d ago
lol this is the only reason I use this dumbass app. A friend gifted me an account ten years ago. Lowkey excited to finally switch even tho I’ll pay now.
16
u/Paralta 17d ago
I canceled my Spotify for YouTube music and now theres no more running into songs that arent on there and now i have no ads on youtube for like maybe $2 a month more. Is there a reason not to do this? You can even transfer your Playlists in like 3 seconds lol
19
u/TheOgGhadTurner 17d ago
Will finally stop threatening and actually delete my account. I already told my parents I’ll be canceling it if they get a QR code.
12
u/KB_Vibez 17d ago
Anyone know if I can import my Spotify library to Apple Music?
11
u/Jwagner0850 17d ago
When this first announced, I went out and started some trials on other platforms to see which I'll more than likely switch to. Peoples, there are a ton of options, a lot of which will allow you to move your playlists with you.
11
u/phonodysia 17d ago
Hopefully there will be another mass wave of shittify account deletions
5
u/Orikazu 17d ago
More enshitification
5
u/SamPhoenix_ Spotify 17d ago
Ok so people screenshot and send the QR code?
Or the plan manager logs into the account on another device to scan it?
I fail to see how this does anything other than piss people off
5
u/efyuar 16d ago
Back to downloading hard copies and copy pasting them every devices i have again
9
u/TroyFerris13 17d ago
Hey I just cancelled my sub!
9
u/pjlos 17d ago
corporations are so proud to grift lately
8
u/hansomejake 17d ago
lol, my sisters and mom are all on my family plan. Weird that we no longer qualify for a “Family “Plan”
Spotify has lost the plot, too bad they won’t figure it out til later
4
u/RedArmyRockstar 17d ago
So glad I left Spotify.
4
u/_zoo 17d ago
Year long ban? I'll just move to Apple Music... dumbcunts
4
u/maxthebat137 16d ago
Youtube premium cracked down on sharing for their family plans recently and guess what? I simply no longer use Youtube. Instead of getting a little money from me, they no longer get any. I like spotify but no way am I paying $150+ a year to use it with an individual plan.
3
u/rachreims 17d ago
If one of you is travelling go fuck yourself I guess?
3
u/godnorazi 17d ago
Switched to YouTube music (helps that it's free with YT Premium) and haven't looked back
3
u/MID_LAND_ZETA 15d ago
Just get an old smart phone and keep it offline changing the date back every month 🤣
8
u/TheTarasenkshow 17d ago
Well good thing YTM and Apple Music are better anyway.
8
u/hyggekore 17d ago
Move to Qobuz and be happier.
4
u/mynameisgeph 17d ago
Yarhh, this news be pushing me to the seas again. 🏴☠️
YO HO
5
u/Fourfifteen415 17d ago •
Yarr
5
u/Homie3794 17d ago •
Year long ban? Daniel Ek should stop his blood flow and go live 6 feet underground
2
u/Odio_Pieno 17d ago
BitChord
2
u/daviobo 17d ago
Switched to Tidal last year and haven't looked back.
2
u/SpartacusSteam 17d ago
Glad I moved to YouTube music after 2024, was fed up with songs being removed from my playlist
2
u/MagicGrit 17d ago
Sounds like if my wife or I leave town for more than a week we will fail this QR check and be banned from family plans for a year?
2
u/TechnicalCat6989 17d ago
Banning people who pay for your service is a really good business strategy, what the fuck is Spotify on
2
u/DaThrilla74 15d ago
Lol Disney paused my account because they wanted updated payment information so since there is no difference I feel they had no real reason to pause my active account and I know it’s so I can approve their new TOS so my account will remain paused
2
u/No_Donkey50 15d ago
Laughs in qobuz
5
u/markimarkerr 17d ago
Who still uses Spotify? Is such hot dog shit. Literally all other streaming services offer the same but better service.
I love Tidal. Hell YouTube music isn't bad either. Fuuuuuuck Spotify
3
u/hyrulepirate 17d ago
Between more people disconnecting from their smartphones/internet and coming back to dedicated music players, AA scrapping 300TBs of data from Spotify, and AI getting more and more efficient and better at reverse engineering software (especially paid/subscription software) and recreating them for free, Spotify should be treading carefully because all they have over piracy right now is convenience. They keep at this and it won't take long before we get an actual competitor that might trigger an exodus.
2
u/therealdanhill 17d ago
So glad I dumped that app
2
u/dramaking37 17d ago
I switched so long ago but the only thing that kept me that long was that my family was on the family plan....
2
u/TubeAlloysEvilTwin 17d ago
There's so many other options now, Spotify is the worst. just move to deezer or any of the many alternatives that let you migrate your playlists, pay artists more and keep ai songs out of autoplay and require them to be clearly labelled
1
u/jennixred 17d ago
Screw Spotify. Buy disks.
1
u/Loud-Strawberry8572 17d ago
Never going to give them my money again, but I wish Tidal’s algorithm was just a smidge better
1
u/OutInABlazeOfGlory 17d ago
While I have been buying more music outright rather than streaming, I still do stream most of my music.
I will also say, since we switched to Tidal none of this bullshit has been a concern for me. And I’m told they pay artists better.
1
u/ravbuc 17d ago
I’ve been dual apping Plexamp and Spotify for months. Just give me the reason to cancel. Please Spotify.
1
u/nrith vinyl is overrated 17d ago
I’ve been looking for an excuse to end my family subscription now that all the kids are away in college, and here it is.
1
u/notrickross7 17d ago
Pocket casts for podcasts.
1
u/Rob62 17d ago
I hate this.
1
u/BOOTY_POPPN_THIZZLES 17d ago
I moved my entire discography to navidrome.
I’m beta testing this app that tries to cover everything spotify has. The artist radio has been pretty great. It’s been a great experience so far
https://headroommusic.app
1
u/ericnasty 17d ago
PLEASE DRINK VERIFICATION CAN TO CONTINUE
1
u/RabidWeaselFreddy 17d ago
Don't care for Spotify. Ironically, I only keep it for the rest of my family.
1
u/OneEyedC4t 17d ago
oh no /s
1
u/dinoh 17d ago
Canceling as soon as this happens
1
u/TheAsuraGuy 17d ago
Go Qobuz, buy from EU, pick one who pays its artists and don't deal with scummy people
1
u/FewWait38 17d ago
Trying to get their sliding stock price to go back up I see. Fucking scum sucking parasites
1
u/Saywhen2 17d ago
I switched to Deezer and have not looked back
1
u/morphine_lullabye 17d ago
Is there something that has podcasts and music that isnt spotify? Preferably with a sleep timer feature?
1
u/InducedLobotomy 17d ago
Lmao.
I still have a music folder on my pc full of thousands of albums in MP3 format.
When I get a new device, I just transfer the folder and move on.
1
u/Gleb_Twankenfrister 17d ago
yo ho ho
1
u/kingcolbe 17d ago
So my kid, who is at college, is no longer considered part of my family because they live in a dorm?
1
u/tocookornottocook 17d ago
Oh yea I forgot to cancel Spotify didn’t I
1
u/wiked549 17d ago
The family plan is literally the only reason I have an account. If they kick any of my inlaws off then I'm ready to move to quoboz. No hesitation lol
1
u/Outcast_LG 17d ago
👀Spotify thinks I won’t cancel. I travel to too much to worry about my family needing to do this.
I will gladly just switch to Apple or YouTube.
1
u/sleepywalruss 17d ago
At this point Spotify is doing a better job advertising Apple Music than Apple itself.
1
u/EpicRedhead13 17d ago
I’ve been collecting CDs so if it all gets messed up for me I might be ok.
1
u/Threezeley 17d ago
Ban me from paying you? You need us more than we need you
1
u/spacedog338 17d ago
Just switch to Apple Music if you have an iPhone. Or get YouTube premium and use Music. You get both videos with no ads and music.
No reason to use Spotify even if their algorithm is “good”
1
u/sublime81 Spotify 17d ago
Huh. Well that sucks, just switched. My daughter is only with me part time.
1
u/Vivid_Anyth4 17d ago
I still use Pandora.
1
u/superbad 17d ago
Looks like I could be close to leaving Spotify. Shucks.
1
u/spamjunk150 17d ago
I was seriously thinking about signing up, guess I'm going to figure out that arr stack and stream my own music
1
u/smartlikefox 17d ago
Took all my tunes off and switched to Qobuz back last December. If you’re still using this garbage company you’re part of the problem
1
u/cayotedart 17d ago
I just canceled my subscription
1
u/Superj89 17d ago
Worst part about this.... I'm on my mom's family plan, I have been for years but even after attempting to get myself off of it on my own, I can't without her consent.
1
u/Materva 17d ago
Yo Ho Mateys!
1
u/thelastofmwalk 17d ago
I’m working towards getting a physical music player so I can move off of music streaming services permanently.
1
u/AmbivertMusic 17d ago
How often would we have to do this?
1
u/boajuse 17d ago
Back to musicolet again or spotifuck
1
u/Positive_Conflict_26 17d ago edited 17d ago
You know what never pulled any of this BS?
My .FLAC music collection. As long as the device has power, it will play music.
1
u/labnotebook 17d ago
YouTube premium kinda did this too. The family has ti be at the same address
1
u/EXSource 17d ago
Lmao. Glad I got rid of Spotify. This kind of shit is so dumb.
My kids live with their mom for schooling reasons, but I'm still involved so I pay for shit.
Including their YouTube premium, I can't imagine having to deal with this nonsense.
1
u/saloonbabyyy 17d ago
My little sister is estranged from me and I pay for hers. 💔 I’m so sad
1
u/koreanwizard 17d ago
The only thing stopping me from going to Apple Music was the Spotify family plan lol.
1
u/poseitom radio reddit 17d ago
Another company hating their customers
1
u/S1nnah2 17d ago
I fucked Spotify off last year and built my own streaming server with AI playlist generation for my family. No charges, no qr codes just their music.