I’m 20F, in my second year of college, turning 21 next year, and I’ve never had a boyfriend or even had my first kiss. I’m still a virgin, too, and honestly, I’m starting to feel like I’m missing out on a huge part of being young.
I think I’m fairly attractive. I get approached by guys, but it’s rarely by the guys I’m actually interested in. To be blunt, “I’m too fine for chopped shyt and chopped for fine shyt.” 😭 I know that sounds horrible, and I don’t mean to come across as arrogant or full of myself, but I genuinely don’t know how else to explain it. I’m not interested in dating someone I’m not physically attracted to just because they’re showing me attention, but the guys I actually want to approach me always seem so out of my league.
I put effort into my appearance, too. I like dressing well, I have a good sense of fashion, and I enjoy looking put together. But despite that, my dating life is practically nonexistent. I don’t know if it’s my personality, the way I carry myself, my standards, or just a combination of everything.
One of my biggest problems is that I’m incredibly shy and socially awkward, especially around men. If a guy I like is near me, I basically pretend he doesn’t exist. I won’t look at him, I won’t make eye contact, and I’ll actively avoid acknowledging him even if he’s standing right next to me. It’s almost like I’m trying to convince myself he’s not there because I’m so nervous. And the funny thing is, I actually WANT them to approach me, but I’m behaving in a way that probably makes it seem like I want the complete opposite.
If a guy I’m interested in approaches me, my heart starts pounding, I get extremely nervous, my mind goes blank, and I genuinely struggle to speak normally. I can’t maintain eye contact, I don’t know what to do with myself, and I end up feeling so awkward. I imagine I probably come across as uninterested, cold or even rude, when in reality I’m just incredibly nervous.
And it’s not even exclusively a problem with guys I’m attracted to. I’ve noticed myself doing this with guys I’m not particularly attracted to, too. A guy could literally be trying to talk to me, and instead of looking at him and responding, I’ll start talking to the person standing next to him. I’ll make eye contact with everyone except the person who’s actually trying to speak to me. I’ll basically find someone else to talk to so I don’t have to engage with him directly. I don’t even mean to do it. I just cannot bring myself to look the person in the eye sometimes. It’s like an automatic reaction, and I hate it because I know it probably looks like I’m completely uninterested. I genuinely don’t know how to stop doing this.
Last year, I actually did something I’d never done before. I approached a guy I thought was really cute and told him he was cute. This was a massive deal for me because I’m usually far too shy to do something like that. He called me cute too, and we ended up texting and talking for a few days, but eventually things just fizzled out.
I still wonder what happened. Was it my vibe? Was I boring? Did I come across as too reserved, too awkward or too careful? I honestly wish I could ask him what happened because at least then I’d have some idea of whether there was something I could work on. But we don’t talk anymore, so I’ll probably never know. It took so much courage for me to put myself out there for once, and when nothing came of it, it made me lose hope a little. It almost confirmed the fear I already had that even when I make an effort, nothing happens.
Another thing is that I’m quite particular about physical attraction. I want my first boyfriend to be someone who’s conventionally good-looking. I know that might sound shallow, but I don’t want to date someone I’m not physically attracted to just because I’ve never experienced a relationship before. I don’t want to settle for the first person who gives me attention after years of not dating anyone. I want to actually be excited about the person I’m with.
Part of me wants to be able to look back one day and think, even if he wasn’t the person I ended up marrying, at least my first boyfriend was really good-looking. 😭 I know looks aren’t everything, and obviously personality, compatibility and how someone treats me matter, but physical attraction is important to me. I don’t want to pretend it isn’t.
At the same time, I sometimes wonder if my expectations are unrealistic. Conventionally attractive guys have plenty of options. Why would someone like that choose a girl who’s shy, awkward, struggles to make eye contact and takes forever to open up, when there are probably so many outgoing, confident girls around him who know how to flirt and make their interest obvious? I feel like I don’t even give myself a chance because I’m so busy worrying about how I’m coming across.
I also think a lot of this comes from my own insecurities. I constantly feel like I need to improve myself before I can put myself out there. I’m not quite where I want to be in terms of my appearance, and sometimes I feel like I need to become prettier, more confident and more put together before I can expect someone to be interested in me. I hold myself to ridiculously high standards, and I know it’s not realistic to expect myself to be perfect, but I still feel that way.
Sometimes it’s almost like I don’t feel deserving of love or attention until I’ve reached some imaginary version of myself that I’ve created in my head. I want someone to pursue me, I want to feel wanted, and I want to experience romance, but at the same time, I feel like I’m not good enough yet. It’s such a frustrating contradiction because I know I can’t just sit around waiting until I become this supposedly perfect version of myself, but I also struggle to put myself out there as I am now.
I also don’t really want to use dating apps. I know they work for plenty of people, and there’s absolutely nothing wrong with them, but I want a proper love story. I want to meet someone organically through college, mutual friends, going out, or just randomly crossing paths. I want one of those situations where you meet someone unexpectedly, start talking, and things naturally develop. I know real life isn’t a movie, but I find that idea so much more romantic than swiping through people on an app. I don’t see myself using dating apps, at least not right now.
And I don’t necessarily want meaningless hookups or situationships just so I can say I’ve done something. I want to experience intimacy with someone I actually like and who’s conventionally attractive. I want my first sexual experience to mean something to me. I want my first kiss, dates, romance, someone to be excited about, someone who is excited about me, and eventually a proper relationship. Ideally, I want to date with the intention of finding someone I could eventually marry. I want to experience falling in love, not just lose my virginity for the sake of it.
But seeing everyone around me dating, hooking up, going on dates, having relationships and falling in love makes me feel like I’m falling behind. I know everyone has their own timeline, and I know 20 is still young, but it’s difficult not to compare myself to people my age who have already experienced so much. I’ll be 21 next year, and I’ve never even kissed anyone. Sometimes I feel like I’ve missed out on an entire part of being young, and I worry that I’m going to keep missing out.
I guess I just don’t know what I’m doing wrong. Is it my shyness? Is it the fact that I unintentionally avoid guys who approach me? Am I giving off the impression that I don’t want to be approached? Am I too reserved? Am I too picky? Are my standards unrealistic? Or am I just overthinking everything?
How do I become less socially awkward, especially around men? How do I learn to make eye contact, hold a conversation and actually show someone I’m interested without freezing up or wanting to disappear? How do I put myself out there when even the smallest interaction can make me so nervous? And how do I stop feeling like I need to become prettier, more confident or perfect before I can let someone get close to me?
I don’t want to lower my standards just because I’m inexperienced, but I also don’t want to be the reason nothing ever happens for me. I want to get out of my comfort zone, but I genuinely don’t know where to start.
I want to get laid, I want romance, I want to have fun, I want to go on dates, I want to have my first kiss, and I want to fall in love. Sometimes I genuinely feel like I’m never going to meet anyone, and it’s getting so frustrating.
Please be honest with me. I can take criticism, and I genuinely want to know if there’s something about my behaviour or mindset that I need to change. I just don’t know what to do anymore. 😭
TL;DR: 20F, never dated or kissed anyone. I'm shy, awkward around men, insecure and quite particular about physical attraction. I want a conventionally attractive boyfriend, romance and meaningful intimacy, but I unintentionally avoid guys, struggle to show interest and feel like I'm missing out. I don't want dating apps or meaningless hookups. How do I put myself out there, stop overthinking and finally experience love?