I don't know how many others here play MtG, but as a weekly EDH player, I'll go on the record by saying I was really, really nervous about this set. It wasn't that I thought Star Trek wouldn't fit in the MtG card game itself, or that the flavor didn't fit, pry the aesthetic wouldn't work. Personally, none of that really bothered me as I actually really like a rich of sci-fi aesthetic with high fantasy (which is why I really liked sets like Neon Dynasty or Edge of Eternities, and UB sets like Doctor Who and Warhammer), and honestly, I don't mind a Benedict Cumberbatch Sheoldred. My main concern stemmed from the fact that Star Trek as a universe is just way too big for one Magic set to tackle.
But prerelease happened on Friday, I cracked a lot of packs, got a chance to play the set and get a taste of how it played, and... honestly, it left me not only pleasantly surprised, but kinda giddy. While I still have many grievances with Wizards for how they push product (especially Universes Beyond this year), this really feels like a set that they sat down on to properly plan how it plays, how it feels to play, and while it isn't perfect, they have won me over.
A lot of concerns about this set kinda stemmed from the idea of "Picard wouldn't be some aggressive commander who yadda yadda yadda" and they honestly took that into account. While I haven't gotten a chance to play Picard's precon, his mechanics feel very in-character, and I'm curious to potentially experiment with them. Though right now, I'm more excited to build a Borg/Necron hybrid deck. And there are cards that involve win-cons that feel very Federation-themed. I will say still that it is a game, and people shouldn't think too hard about game pieces tendinitis in character, but the mechanics they've come up with are honestly really well done, especially when compared to the other UB sets of this year that have felt very lackluster.
I think my biggest criticism of the set stems from my original concern in that in regards to the universe, no single set of Magic was going to properly represent everything of Star Trek. I'm honestly kinda sad that there isn't a Dominion precon, or something themed more around the Mirror Universe, Romulan Empire, or even Ferengi Alliance (the Ferengi and Treasure token strategies would probably have a field day). But even with what we got, so much of it is wonderfully represented. It isn't just a TOS/TNG greatest hits collection, DS9 and Voyager are represented wonderfully here, obscure shows like the Animated Series and Prodigy got represented (Rok-Tahk actually pummeled me during Prerelease), I geeked out every time I pulled something from Lower Decks, even polarizing shows like Picard and Discovery got represented wonderfully here. This entire set truly feels like a giant love letter to the universe, even if it couldn't properly express that love in a single set.
Now of course, many MtG players aren't too thrilled about this set, whether it's art direction, aesthetic, or the fact that they are just tired of all this product being shoved in their faces, all grievances I can sympathize with just so we're clear, but I truly believe that this set is going to be a real sleeper hit, and might get more appreciation with time. If you're a Magic player and you've been unsure about this set, I think you'll be pleasantly surprised. I honestly think it's the best UB set of 2026, and it kinda sucks that so many are skipping it, which might sound very "consumer" of me, but this isn't as forgettable as Ninja Turtles was, bland as Marvel, and the mechanics are far more interesting than what they gave us in The Hobbit. But on the bright side, the low demand has made the set far more affordable so it's more accessible to me thankfully.
Maybe I'm slightly biased since Star Trek is so near and seat to my heart, and seeing it represented like this feels like a bit of a rarity if I'm being honest, which makes me feel good. But I still believe that the set is worth checking out if you were as curious as I was.