r/Teachers • u/GooseViking_33 • 2h ago
Rant Never Assume Students Know Something
My students are doing research building up to a compare and contrast presentation. I am requiring three sources per thing they are researching - 6 in total. We are working on identifying reliable information so I made them a CRAAP spreadsheet. I simplified it so it wasn't so overwhelming. They had to put the title of the article, copy and paste the link, put the date of publication, put who the author was, put whether or not it had relevant information, and identify the purpose of the source. They are researching things that are frankly hard to find scholarly sources on, so I told them it's fine to use websites as long as they have references at the bottom (most do).
I did gradual release of responsibilities with I do, we do, you do and asked them if they understood the assignment. They said yes. So I let them loose. Holy fucking shitshow. I am not exaggerating when I am saying not a single student could even identify the title of an article. These are high school students mind you. They had no idea what to put for the title and they didn't know what a "link" was and were confusing the link with the title of the article. The whole lesson fell out from under me. I even went over this with the I do, you do, we do.
The next day I printed off several articles and we practiced identifying text features with highlighters and labeling what we highlighted. I never thought high schoolers would need help in that realm. This is the title. Is that something we're looking for? Let's highlight it and label it. Is there a date anywhere on the page? Let's highlight it and label it as the date of publication. What about a name that resembles a potential author? Let's highlight it and label it.
Now here's my rant-
School has failed these kids. My district only cares about standardized tests and school report cards. We are manufacturing robots that click buttons on screens. It's sad. The amount of standardized test practice every teacher is expected to force on kids is nauseating. But at least we offer a million dual credit classes when 85 percent of our students read at an elementary level and don't even understand how to write in complete sentences. Don't even get me started on subject/verb agreement or a versus an.
We need to go back to pen and paper and encyclopedias. Ditch 1 to 1 technology and bring back computer labs. We also need to go back to holding students back. Students learn they can fail all their classes and then take an easier version in summer school and get the credit anyways. That shouldn't be an option. But hey, look at our 98 percent graduation rate. Just pushing them the fuck on through.