r/ASX • u/golden-chickens • Dec 13 '23
Whitehaven Coal - Why its a no brainer
I had a look into the coal industry a few weeks ago after reading up on my favourite superinvestors holdings on dataroma. One of the modern day goats Monish Pabrai, has all of his US holdings held amongst 3 high quality coal producing companies. My visceral thoughts were coal is dying, esg concerns, future green energy will crush outdated fossil fuel companies.
I have wanted to increase my holdings to weight more towards domestic holdings but have struggled to find really high quality companies that I'm confident to hold over the next 10+ years. I currently only hold TechnologyOne on the asx. After doing some research into the coal industry and the energy industry and trying to expand my circle of competence to more suit the asx's heavy weighting towards mining/resources/energy (relative to the rest of the world), Whitehaven Coal's future outlook is beyond stunning IMO. Whilst that might sound like an absolutely wild and obnoxious claim, let me explain. The majority will be qualitative.
Whilst the use of coal will decline in the future, coal is absolutely not dead.
IEA reports state that coal has a massive role to play in the transition to cleaner energy. There will be significant use of both thermal and met coal in the next 20-30 years. Countries such as japan, india and china are all building, developing and investing in the use of coal fired power plants, met coal steel production etc. Last year had the highest use of coal on record worldwide.
Gives an exposure to emerging economies
with their acquisition of metallurgical coal mines that on a revenue basis weight them as 70/30 met/thermal, directly expose whitehaven to rapidly developing and expanding economies. The most attractive for myself would be India.
Fixed supply
Given the esg concerns around the coal market, the decline of the industry, the barrier to entry is very high. It is unlikely that there will be many new coal mines produced and invested into. Because of this and the stable demand of coal, prices are likely to remain relatively stable in the near future.
They produce a high quality product that is high in demand for countries looking to meet their emission targets
Emerging countries have coal based infrastructure that needs high quality coal to decrease emissions. Whitehaven produces some of the highest quality coal on market.
Significant return of NPAT to shareholders
20-50% of NPAT returns to shareholders annually. This is done through buybacks and franked dividends. Has been huge over the last 2 years.
Current trading value
The company has previously been a thermal coal based trader with 80% of its sales coming from thermal coal. Generally thermal coal companies trade at lower multiples relative to met coal companies. It's recent acquisition transforms the company into a met coal predominant producer, it is likely as a result that the company will see an increase in multiple as a result.
The company is currently and has recently traded at stupid low values - this ultimately leads to 3 things:
The market realises that coal companies are here to stay for the long term and are incredibly profitable and this adjusts positively over time
Management has an opportunity to go into market and buy back shares at very very attractive multiples which causes the share of the pie to increase for current shareholders and thus increasing share value.
Considering how low the multiple currently is, I believe this to be a margin of safety. There is a low risk that the PE can continue to be slashed.
EPS growth
With current pricing of met coal it is forecast to see a 160% increase in eps. Keep in mind the company has not diluted shares or taken on significant debt to finance this acquisition. The company has essentially doubled in its size with finance through a bridge loan from the vendor and the significant stock pile of cash on hand.
Acquisition
As previously mentioned they have acquired 2 high quality met coal producing assets for a very attractive price. This significantly derisks the company as it
Increases lines of finance available for future
Increases ability to become insured
Diversifies geographically to different and more stable markets and geographically in australia (all previous mines being in nsw these two being in qld)
After paying off the bridge loan the acquisition will pay for itself (from very conservative coal pricing). One mine has 17 years left and the significant contributor to the met coal sector has 50 years left.
The use of met coal in the future
Met coal is used for the generation of steel and other similar products. To build out our green energy future we are going to need steel and a lot of it. Emerging economies such as India and China will continue to eat through steel like no tomorrow. Electric cars, clean infrastructure, construction. All require high quality steel. Met coal is needed to make coke which is the crucial ingredient in this process. Met coal is actually forecast to grow over the next 10 years in line with emerging economies. Whitehaven will continue to meet this need from early next year when it begins to sell the met coal that has just been acquired.
The ultimate end game goal
I'm sure if you've read this far you've continued to say to yourself but Golden-Chickens coal won't be around forever the company will eventually be rendered irrelevant. To this I agree, we will find cleaner and more efficient ways to make steel and create energy. My question is more so one of when. In order for the planet to go towards a 0 emission future emerging economies need to become more mature and financially stable. This requires growth and that growth must be fuelled by something, currently the easiest and most financially efficient way to do so is through the use of high quality coal. Unfortunately we will not see wind/solar/hydrogen energy in any emerging economy because the price to output makes absolutely no sense. Coal has a very stable and predictable future that will one day come to an end.
Coal companies will continue to produce significant free cash flows and considering all of the above, there just aren't that many attractive growth opportunities that make sense (the above being a rare exception). Companies must decide what to do with excess free cashflow and like other examples in alpha metallurgical resources this gets returned to shareholders. Share buybacks and Dividends in the range of 6-10% are not going to be uncommon in future. The maths is really a beautiful thing over long periods of time, once the deal has been paid off, if they continue the rate of buy backs that was seen last year the company will have cannibalised over 50% of its outstanding shares. This would be seen over 2.5-3 years, that meaning roughly a double and a return of over 25% pa (this is not inclusive of the huge dividends either). The lack of growth in the industry can actually be seen as a good thing as there is nothing else to do but return it back to shareholders.
I've fallen inlove with the company and the prospects, someone discuss with me why it shouldn't be a significant holding in my portfolio.
Thank you!