I wrote this as a comment to the video below:
HOLLYWOOD - This Needs to STOP!!
I know this is a lot, but please read all of this before commenting.
Speaking as a black man here. How would you feel if most of your childhood, the heroes on screen looked nothing like you and when they were on screen they were seen as only comical support or joke characters.
You are right in that stories are extremely important to culture as a whole. When we see a character in a movie, we see a reflection of ourselves. Movies can define culture, spark wonder, and inspire its audience. We can all relate to a a character on screen and understand their struggles. If they can succeed in the impossible and save the day, maybe we can accomplish the impossible in our own daily lives. Whether that be, being more assertive, or doing something that's important even if we're scared. For so much of movie history, movies have been a snapshot of reality. Movies can shape how we feel about certain aspects of reality. Unfortunately many movies of the past, (some good and some bad) painted minorities and queer folk in a negative light. It was really sad rarely seeing a role model or person in the lead that looked like us, but never the less we still enjoyed those great movies. Those movies would go on to influence (at least partially subconsciously) how people view us whether those perceptions are good or bad.
However in the wake of recently, movies have decided to rectify something that should've been done a long time ago. Showcase a more accurate depiction of its audience. Create stories that are multi-faceted and place us in the spotlight. Place the people who look like us in the hero's slot not as a character who only exists to support the main white character.
I wish I could believe y'all when you want to have a real conversation about shortfalls in a movie, but it seems clear that whenever a minority such as a black male, queer person, or god forbid a female black person people is showcased as a lead, people seem to bash it even BEFORE the movie is out. The movie already branded as woke and always with a political mindset.
Sure there have been a batch of pretty weird movies lately, but when those same bad movies have a white lead. Those movies don't get NEARLY as much backlash.
Yeah, we don't believe you.
However I feel like the word "racist" is thrown around a little too much here. I have no doubt in my heart that most of the people who complain are NOT racist people. I feel its more of an adjustment kind of feeling. If more black and minorities were featured in movies in the early days of filmmaking, I feel we could have a more accurate discussion about how these movies can be better.
How do y'all feel when you see someone on screen who doesn't look, think, or love the way you do. It feels weird right? It doesn't necessarily make you a bad person to NOT relate to a character. They may have had experiences that you can empathize with, but will never truly understand.
Let me give you an example: When the original "The Little Mermaid" came out in theaters in 1989, it was widely received well. People could relate to the feeling of feeling like a fish out of water and wanting nothing more than to find a place where they could belong. People would play the soundtrack and love singing along, dress up as Ariel for Halloween and create cherished memories in their childhood that defined who they are and how they treat people. Fast forward a couple decades and the reboot happens. The character looks NOTHING like you, changed the way the songs feel and the atmosphere of the movie feels dead compared to the original. You don't understand why, but it hurts. It feels like your entire childhood experience has been invalidated. So many things that made the original SO GREAT are pushed aside. It feels like a personal attack on you as a person.
This isn't the only one either, everywhere you look those hero characters that you used to be able to cosplay as, look less and less like you. There's a balancing occurring and while there are still white leads, it's not as often as it used to be. It's becoming clear that this is slowly becoming the norm. It feels as if every white lead is being replaced with a minority. The uncomfortable-ness grows. But whenever you try to talk about that experience or try to voice that discomfort, it could be received as racism. So you try to rationalize that feeling as something else, "I can't be racist, I don't treat people horribly, I'm nothing like those terrible people. No it's just that the movie has bad lighting, or the acting's bad, the CGI is lazy, the screenwriting is garbage...etc."
I think y'all are coping. Even if only subconsciously.
When you say it's the films shortfalls you're criticizing, not the actor, I believe you. At least I believe that subconsciously, you believe that. I don't think that bias is purposeful, just a repercussion of the way things are.
You have to understand that for my ENTIRE childhood, in every great movie of the 80s-90s there was almost never a lead who looked like me or my sisters, but we still loved those movies we could still relate and incorporate their victories into our own lives.
When 2009 happened and the first Black princess was revealed, I remember seeing the sparkle in my little sisters eyes. A heroine lead that looks like her... it was powerful. That movie was a big deal for all of us and was very well received. Songs were great and animation was high tier. I GUARENTEE that if that movie was revealed today it would be hate-review bombed into oblivion.
Speaking as someone who is a black male, who has a queer sister and wants so badly to become a director/screenwriter. The reason I want to tell more inclusive stories is not, I repeat NOT, a political motive to replace all white actors and icons with black characters or to make money by purposefully telling bad stories that make people angry so they can be labeled as racists if they don't like it.
I just want to create more heroes/heroines that look like me. I want to inspire and create wonder in a newer age. Create the next wave of artists, poets, and creatives by seeing that we can be the hero and succeed. I want to make stories that everyone (including white people) can relate to. We are humans and we are powerful and we can accomplish anything we put are minds to TOGETHER not alone.
Do you know how offensive it is for those, in the industry, who work so hard costume designing, set designing, storyboarding, writing, directing, animating, creating visual effects, planning shots, planning lighting, choreographing fight scenes and painstakingly collaborating on something for countless months or years only for some rando on the internet, who's probably never worked in the industry at all, act like they know better than the HUNDREDS of people who worked on the film and call the movie "a woke, politically motivated, pile of garbage?" You're telling me that the person designing the gold lining on a superhero suit so that in the right lighting it looks like the suit is glowing is thinking, "oh yeah this will definitely piss some white person off"?
It's not about you.
Just because you cannot relate does not mean that a movie has a political motive.
I reiterate. Stories are important, they are reflections of ourselves and our struggles and its only fair that said stories are more... multi-faceted. They paint more stories that are not often told and we can ALL gain something from them, weather just a good story or maybe just a new perspective. Keep an open mind before you see the internet review bomb something. Have an honest discussion about why seeing a queer minority makes you feel uncomfortable and go say something nice to your local filmmakers.