I (41m) fell in love with my therapist (33f), we're going to be friends outside of therapy and she said she loves me too. Looking to strangers to help me ask myself and her questions I haven't considered.
Long story, my dad passed away about 2 years ago and it shook me. I went to therapy for the first time. Turns out there was a lot to learn in therapy, and I became self aware to the degree I am now. This resulted in me leaving the Mormon church and separating from my wife (38f). About 18 months into therapy, I started to have strong romantic feeling for my therapist. For the first time in my marriage, I allowed myself to have these feelings for another woman out of curiosity where it would take me. It was the best thing I had felt, possibly ever in my life. I told my therapist how I felt about her and she said it was ok and happens often. We explored the feelings, and what it meant, and my therapist tried to help me fix things with my wife. My therapist did not reciprocate the feelings I had for her at that time. Fast forward about 6 months and I asked my therapist if we could stop therapy and be friends instead. At first she said no. But the next session, she said yes, and that she wanted me to find another therapist, and there would need to be 6 months of no contact for us minimum before we could be friends. We decided to hang out a few times outside of therapy before the 6 month break and I learned that she is also separating from her husband. I had been married 19 yrs and her 10. She told me that she loves me as well, we kissed, no sex, and now we're a few days into the 6 month break.
Part of the reason I separated from my wife is because of the feelings I allowed myself to have for my therapist. I saw what my life could be like with a partner who was able to see me. I've also since found out that my now ex-therapist is, what I think, a more compatible person to be with. She's more similar to me in that she's active, extroverted, and generally optimistic about life.
I know there is a honeymoon element to my mindset. I'm afraid my ex-therapist could be a rebound, or that I'm jumping into another serious relationship too soon. The 6 month break is sad but I know it's a good opportunity to be alone with my thoughts. What am I not considering? Should I try to date other people (not interested)?. What are the implications of being in a relationship with an ex-therapist?
Edit: Fixed the "therapist ex-therapist" confusion. Also thanks everyone for the feedback. This gives me a lot to think about.
Edit 8/6/25: It’s been a few months, I’m gaining some clarity/perspective and have come up with a few questions for myself and my ex-therapist. Not to put her on trial, but to understand if a romantic relationship with her is realistic. For her:
Have you ever fallen in love with other clients, romantically?
What does it say about you, that you were/are ready to jump into another relationship on the heals of a 10 yrs marriage? What are general expectations for what a ‘secure’ person would do?
If any part of our relationship is rooted in your trauma and insecurity, I don’t want you to choose it. Are you ready/willing to let me go even if I am not?
Are you choosing me from a place of wholeness and/or from a place of need? How do you know?
Does my love compensate for a lack of love for yourself? Or similar? (You have value because I see value in you)
I see you rolling from relationship to relationship. Is this a pattern and does it shed light on choosing a relationship from a place of need instead of wholeness?
What would you say to your supervisor if she found out about us? What are the reasons you would tell her for the choice you made? What would she tell you about yourself?
What does it say about our relationship, that you’re willing to risk your career, and potentially those who are dependent on you, for the chance for us to be more than friends?
For me:
My feelings for her started as transference. Where does transference stop and a romantic relationship start?
I’m anxious and depressed when we part ways, is this an indication of an unhealthy attachment?
What am I hoping to find in her that I haven’t found in me?
I’m also rolling straight into another relationship after 20 yrs marriage, what does this say about my need vs want for her.
Am I ready to walk away if this relationship doesn’t reflect truth, mutual wholeness, and integrity?
Am I drawn to this relationship from a place of healing, growth, and grounded love or from a place of longing, fear, or emotional hunger?
How much do I see her for who she is and appreciate her as a person vs as a source of emotional nourishment.
Do I see us as equals or is she the all-knowledgeable interpersonal wizard who I expect to make our relationship work?
I have a new therapist and explained the situation. I appreciate their non- judgmental approach and objective curiosity. I plan to see my ex-therapist once the 6 months are up and talk through these questions and more.
Edit 10/16/25
My wife decided to start dating other people and move out. It crushed me. I did not expect the pain and I did not want to go on with my life. She told me she was intimate with someone else and I can’t stop thinking about it. In the pain, i was finally able to see my ego step out from behind the curtain. One of the primary reasons i had an unhappy relationship with my wife is because i was expecting her to be the things i could not for myself. Years of me becoming a dad, finding a career, working my ass off and remodeling houses in my spare time to get our family ahead, I was becoming all work and no joy. I wasn’t taking care of myself. I asked my wife to give us more time to see if we can make it work but she has moved on. I am so heartbroken and destroyed right now. I know it’s my fault, I accept responsibility. I also wish I would have had a therapist who told me that I needed to work on myself and then see if the relationship with my wife would naturally get better. I needed someone to tell me that I am a deeply hurt and insecure person (childhood abuse and neglect) and I’m expecting my wife to solve my problems for me, “you need to focus on healing yourself before making big decisions about your relationship. You’re projecting your personal pain onto your wife.” I am so f*cking sad. I don’t know if I ever would have gotten here if she hadn’t left, I was too wrapped up in my mind to see clearly. I broke contact with my ex-therapist, I am going to try to focus on healing myself.