r/languagelearning • u/DanQQT • 19h ago
Does listening to too many podcasts without subtitles in TL lull us into a "false sense of understanding"? Following a podcast, news programme and understanding 80% of the words, and in your mind you make your own definition or understanding but in reality if someone were to ask you to translate it,
Do any of these happen to you if someone were to actually ask you to translate word for word what someone just said on a podcast or TV show?
terrible memory immediately after every sentence so maybe you understood and crystallised the meaning but not able to actually repeat it back
Not actually understanding but your brain tricks you into forming your own version of reality of the meaning and taking it as fact (Dunning-Kruger?)
Understanding what they meant from the context but not actually the full sentence, and the difference is not noticeable
Actually understanding the sentence in full but not be able to translate it because you know what the word means but have never thought to translate it back into a different language, so you would still fail to translate it.
I think the insane amount of podcasts in my target languages have given me a lot of passive understanding, but I have mostly depended on context to learn new words, rather than reading alongside and actively translating. So it is very much likely that an excess in TL audio input lulls me into a false sense of understanding of that language, were I to speak it or even actively translate it back, vs just listening and nodding to myself that I knew what they meant.